Ex: A Mercedes C300 might cost $420/month, but the effective price is $800/month considering fuel & maintenance. Is that also problematic?
Most people will initially compare the Model S'$60k price tag vs $40k for a Mercedes, but the total ownership cost figures tell a different story.
A friend of mine makes a road trip every week for business. Do they also add the cost of the time you spend waiting for a charge at charging stations vs a quicker gas pump for road trips? A full charge is about an hour. Should the price be higher for him?
Look, I'm not saying it's still not a decent bargain when all is said and done, I'm just saying you can't roll it into your 'cost' and advertise that as the price you want me to pay. I am not paying that. I'm paying 190 bucks more a month based on my current fuel usage. My friend would be paying for it in an extra hour a week at least. These things count too.
You'll see they actually do the opposite, discounting for saved time, since 90% of the time you'll just plug it in at home and never worry about recharging during the day, instead of a trip to the gas station every week.
If I decide to get a Tesla instead of bike to work does the Tesla now cost more than $900?
Yes, if you park the car and never drive it, the gasoline-fueled vehicle will be cheaper. But that isn't a meaningful use case. I don't get the controversy...?
It just doesn't make the slightest bit of sense.
If your transportation budget includes $1200 a month for gasoline, then you could get another Tesla simply by giving $900/month to Tesla instead of the oil companies.
(All of this assumes that the cost of electricity is free, which is of course bogus.)
$200/month adds up to almost $10k over 4 years.
By talking about gasoline cost in their car price calculator, Tesla is going for a "total cost of ownership" thing, so why is battery replacement cost not included?
It looks to me as if Tesla is eager to talk loudly about the unique costs of their competitors, while keeping quiet about the unique costs of themselves.
Forgive me if I lose my balance due to how hard I rolled my eyes.
During the period between 36 months to 39 months from your Guarantee Effective Date, you have the option to sell your vehicle to Tesla for the Guaranteed Resale Value. [...] This Guarantee automatically expires on the 39 month anniversary of the Guarantee Effective Date.
http://www.teslamotors.com/sites/default/files/pdfs/tesla-re...
It's disappointing to see that Tesla still relying on misrepresentations to sell its cars.
Tesla marketing is simply doing their job and making sure consumers don't forget to add the price of gas to gasoline cars, by making a point of subtracting it from their car.
If I bought a Tesla it would mostly be replacing bus trips not another car. That shouldn't have an impact on the cost of owning a Tesla.
The problem is, when you tell someone their $30k car actually ends up costing $70k over a few years, they have a knee-jerk reaction (as seen in this thread) - "I don't spend that much" / "Gasoline hardly makes a difference" / "Maintenance costs nearly nothing".
They are basically saying a Model S will affect your monthly budget as much as a $580/month car, I see that as absolutely fair.
Google suggests the "average" car actually has higher resale value, at the same age/mileage, than what Tesla is guaranteeing: (I guess they're comparing to a subclass of luxury car which depreciates faster)
http://www.edmunds.com/car-buying/how-fast-does-my-new-car-l...
Is he subtracting fuel savings from the car price? I recall there was an HN thread complaining about this but I can't find it...
Here's the calculator. They claim an "effective cost" of $579/month (default choices), which it seems means $917/month in actual payments, plus negative $261/month in fuel savings:
http://www.teslamotors.com/true-cost-of-ownership