Re:Don’t build. Compose
by L0j1k on Saturday May 04, 2013 @01:37AM
(#5654139)
To someone that doesn't actually write code, sure, it may be just that easy to use terminology alone to draw the parallel.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Your comment seems unduly negative. But, after reading the article it really does seem like a forced analogy.
I suppose in some ways it's quite surprising that writing code is so much different than writing a novel. They are after all linear sequences of statements. But a novel is always trying to draw you toward the end, to a conclusion. The lasting ideas it places in your mind, it does using indirect means. A computer program on the other hand creates something dynamic and non-linear.
What surprised after reading the article is how little I felt writing code, even narrative driven games, is like writing a novel.
I think that's what struck me most about this, that it felt forced, and also written by someone that doesn't quite understand exactly what programming actually is and is not. Writing a novel? No. I'd say it's much more like building a bridge than writing a novel. We use small machines to build a bigger structure that serves a purpose. That's why I accused the author of not knowing much about programming (indeed, he is a self-described "product guy"). Otherwise he'd be much more likely to draw parallels with building bridges or some other kind of engineering than writing a novel or authoring some other literary product.