Re: The Lies You've Been Told About the Origin of the QWERTY...
by bitwize on Friday May 03, 2013 @03:32PM
(#5652148)
The truth doesn't matter anymore. The meme that "QWERTY was designed to be inefficient, caught on, and now we're stuck with it" has mythical emotive power, much like "women were worshipped for their mysterious ability to give birth, before agriculture gave us the patriarchy", so much so that Alan Kay still uses "a QWERTY keyboard situation" to describe "network effects of something designed to suck"; and layout hipsters will be touting the superiority of their Dvořák layouts long after the time_t-pocalypse twenty-five years hence.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re: The Lies You've Been Told About the Origin of the QWERTY...
by ZeroGravitas on Friday May 03, 2013 @05:29PM
(#5652752)
If you read the paper the actual reasons they propose for qwerty are as bizarre and anti-ergonomic as the arm jamming and "typewriter" demo theory. Namely: putting z,c,e together to help with decoding Morse. Putting the letters i and o near 8 to help type the years 1870 and 1871 faster (early keyboards had no zero and one key), and (topically) switching a couple of other letters to avoid patents, but still vaguely following the original idea of a-m going right and then n-z going left on a piano style keyboard.
This paper completely supports the view that old decisions stick around long after they are no longer relevant even if the exact details differ from the standard version.