If you're only getting grocery store quality ingredients at a fine dining restaurant, you're getting ripped off.
Agreed, that is part of it. But I will contend that a 4x increase in price does not reflect a 4x increase in the quality of the ingredients. Now, granted, that's all very subjective and hard to measure. And all I have is anecdotal evidence, but on the occasions when I have found myself paying $80.00 or more for a steak, I've never finished it and thought "wow that was 4 times better than the $20.00 steak I had last week".
If you're only getting grocery store quality ingredients at a fine dining restaurant, you're getting ripped off.
Fair enough. I agree that ingredients do matter, just not sure they fully justify the higher price of the nicer restaurants. Having grown up at the coast, near Holden Beach, NC, I got used to eating very fresh seafood. Now, when I have seafood further inland, I can definitely notice a difference based on the ingredients not being as fresh. That actually leads to a bit of a paradox... some restaurants, just due to their location, will never be able to replicate the best possible seafood experience, due to the need to transport ingredients. So the $50.00 seafood meal you eat at a restaurant in, say, St. Louis, probably won't be as good in some regards as a $15.00 meal you could have in Calabash, NC, just due to geography.
Meh. In my experience you reach a point of diminishing returns very quickly, in terms of price / quality ratio at "fine dining" restaurants. Paying $40.00 for a steak gets you a significantly better steak than the $15.00 one, yes. But paying $80.00 for a steak doesn't get you much more, if any more than the $40.00 steak. And I, for one, have no problem believing that a home chef can replicate the $40.00 steak in their own kitchen.
Most of what you're paying for at those upscale, trendy, fine-dining places is service, ambiance, status-signalling,ego gratification, etc. You don't pay 4 times more for a meal because you expect the food to be 4 times better.