Re:The Cult Of Positive Attitude and Always Saying Yes
by mindcrime on Friday May 03, 2013 @12:22PM
(#5650891)
I see them more like a construction. Someone presents their view point, and if its not what I see as truth, its not my job to "argue" it, its now OUR job to figure out truth. So the conversation should be a back and forth of explanation until the truth is agreed upon. This does require both participants to be willing to change their viewpoint, which I agree people need to be better at.
Very, very well said. I agree wholeheartedly. "Collaboration, not arguing" is one way I'd phrase it.
I think that mindset is why I get frustrated with people on HN sometimes. If I say something, I'm not necessarily interested in having a high-school debate-club debate over it... I'm interested in finding a shared understanding of the truth and finding the common ground. Not all "discussions" need to be treated as "debates" damnit. :-)
My advice to the author would be to do as I've done with this comment: look for where the other person is coming from and realize that there are reasons people say and do the things they say and do. Then, instead of attacking, approach it as an opportunity for both of you to learn something new by sharing your differing viewpoints and converging on the truth. I'm looking forward to discovering the truth of how best to handle these situations based on the experience provided in by those who may respond to my comment!
Absolutely. I could not agree more.
On a related note, there's an old saying I heard once, that goes something like "Be kind, because everyone is fighting their own battles also". Being considerate and tolerant doesn't cost us anymore than being dick'ish and argumentative, so why not do it?
Very, very well said. I agree wholeheartedly. "Collaboration, not arguing" is one way I'd phrase it.
I think that mindset is why I get frustrated with people on HN sometimes. If I say something, I'm not necessarily interested in having a high-school debate-club debate over it... I'm interested in finding a shared understanding of the truth and finding the common ground. Not all "discussions" need to be treated as "debates" damnit. :-)
My advice to the author would be to do as I've done with this comment: look for where the other person is coming from and realize that there are reasons people say and do the things they say and do. Then, instead of attacking, approach it as an opportunity for both of you to learn something new by sharing your differing viewpoints and converging on the truth. I'm looking forward to discovering the truth of how best to handle these situations based on the experience provided in by those who may respond to my comment!
Absolutely. I could not agree more.
On a related note, there's an old saying I heard once, that goes something like "Be kind, because everyone is fighting their own battles also". Being considerate and tolerant doesn't cost us anymore than being dick'ish and argumentative, so why not do it?