Thanks for the clarification. I hadn't noticed the right-click to whitelist option before. I'll have to go change the preference back.
I don't know if the software I was using was just old or if signing isn't common place yet, but I felt like I got prompted while trying to use some fairly popular software.
Wrong, the default Gatekeeper setting is set so that:
- you don't have to if the software is recent and signed by the developer.
- you don't have to either for unsigned code: as explained in the dialog that pops up, you can right click instead and choose open, which will pop up a similar dialog alllowing you to whitelist this app only.
Threfore, don't ever turn off Gatekeeper in Preferences.