Well they do this in Australia... http://www.news.com.au/money/banking/computer-glitch-hits-cb...
> "People were running past me screaming 'Free money! Free money!'," Punchbowl Pharmacy manager Feriale Zakhia said of the people using a nearby ATM.
> "Everyone was so happy. They were running around with huge smiles."
> [A technical problem] forced the bank to put all of their ATM machines into offline mode. Customers had no access to their account balance but were still able to withdraw money - more than their accounts held.
> Those withdrawal limits are up to $2000 a day for holders of keycards and debit Mastercards.
> "No one has received free cash," Mr Fitzgerald said. "What they've done is overdrawn their accounts. We will be following those people up and recovering that money."
In that case, the ATM was disconnected from the accounting system and allowed withdrawals up to a set limit ($2000), but it (probably, the article is unclear) was still connected to the authorization system.
It (probably) still checked your PIN, and checked whether your card had been cancelled, etc. It just didn't connect through to check your balance.
As Jeremy said if for some reason we can't reach the checking account system we'll authorize up to $xxx total for the day on a stand-in basis
In this case some reason == "[A technical problem]" and xxx == $2000
BTW I've been scammed out of money by ATMs before - money was withdrawn from my account but some system jammed and I didn't get the money - and the bank was awfully uncooperative.
So far I've had more luck with the "money under the mattress" method than with banks - and I wasn't trapped in the "Corralito" or other bank-aided money-stealing schemes
Ecuador and Brazil also had their own versions. In the Uruguayan version, they didn't forcibly exchange the money, but they froze all bank assets for 3 years (losing out on interest, investment opportunities, exchange rates, etc...).
Uruguay is more trustworthy (especially with foreign investment) but it's not above such things.
Currently there's a big scare due to the huge exchange rate disparity with Argentina - which has an "official" exchange rate and a "real" exchange rate which is almost double the official one, and makes Uruguay non-competitive.
Edit: you're from Argentina, that's obviously not news for you :)
I'm sure that, under the hood, there are a lot of ACIDic transactions going on, but, stepping back, it still looks pretty BASEic. When I hit "withdraw $200", there is no guarantee that my actual account has a transaction commit for that amount. Instead, there may just be a log message saying "SoftwareMaven withdrew $200".
I don't really think it is useful to try and use the terms ACID/BASE to refer to the aggreggate process behavior of an entire industry's technology. Not that it is wrong, it just really doesn't mean anything at that point. Most data interchange that takes place between thousands of different parties is going to have similar characteristics. Maybe a market/exchange is a good counter-example but I can't think of many others.
I believe some of the first ATMs actually worked offline (the PIN was encoded on the magentic stripe), but networked models came out a few years later. Of course, this was in the late 1960s, when card readers (and the expertise to use them) were far harder to obtain.
Exactly--the ecosystem as a whole is BASE, but the individual systems are ACID, and the "eventual consistency" aspect is implemented as first-class logic in applications/processes.
I think BASE is a good ecosystem-level principle, but when it gets into datastores, then each individual system doesn't know what it's true opinion of the world is, much less how it can effectively coordinate with other similarly potentially confused systems.
Source: I am a former software engineer for a credit card transaction system vendor.
I don't think so. I support ATM client software for a large bank in the US and we certainly don't do this. This may be true for "remote" ATMs that are installed in convenience stores on POTS. I can't say I've ever actually heard of it though - the main problem with this idea is that cards cannot be authenticated without network access, and just spewing out money to every piece of plastic calling itself a card when your network connection has been dropped isn't really a recipe for success. Fraud is a real problem.
The ATM client software I support cannot do any transactions without a connection with its authorization system. That authorization system though, can stand-in for the various accounting systems and external networks up to pre-defined limits. So for example if for some reason we can't reach the checking account system we'll authorize up to $xxx total for the day on a stand-in basis. The transaction with the authorization system is definitely ACID; the ATM will not get a response code authorizing a withdrawal unless the transaction has been recorded in the authorization system. The account system may well be caught up later. The funny thing is, ACID is a property of individual database systems and it has absolutely nothing to with a question of whether two separate ledgers are guaranteed to be changed together or not at all. That would be the job of a distributed transaction coordinator - and those really are not used very much in banking. Instead there is a protocol of credits and debits and a settlement process to work out the exceptions. Maybe this is what the article was trying to say up to a point but they sort of confused the issue between the point of view of the ATM and the accounting systems of record.