I think you might be doing that "my default is to just find fault" thing that someone was writing about in a blog post that got submitted to HN in the last few days. This looks like a nice service, and while I would never send a handwritten card myself (I hate to write by hand), I would be touched to receive one of these, even if it had come out of a printer.
Because of that, people have learned to discriminate between modern computer print, classical printing, and handwriting (the latter two leave impressions on the paper), so that they can distinguish the real thing from, say, a personalized "Congratulations, mr. Smith, you have won a million" letter sent by some marketing department.
You're not stupid, and after you've gotten a few of these, it's just pathetic and has the opposite effect. (Plus, SendOutCards is plastered all over the back of the card with a referral code so the person can sign you up - cause it's an MLM!)
Felt isn't trying to attract that same type of user. And it's actually your handwriting. I think, when it's real people genuinely using this to be real - it WILL come across with the right sentiment. I like what they're doing.
At the end of the process a Felt card feels authentic. I'd love to write you one if you'd like. Just email me you address.
Felt will never feel as "authentic" as the very premise of the app is to reduce, if not eliminate, the reason for sending handwritten cards.
Some people prefer to hand-write letters and will probably do so until they die. Some occasions require hand-written letters and will probably do so for a very long time to come. (Felt technically is hand-writing so I guess I mean non-digital hand-writing... Do we need to invent a new term?)
I don't think Felt is necessarily trying to compete with the above, it's simply trying to offer a middle-ground between text messages and inked letters. If we look at how quickly communication has changed (some might say devolved) over the last twenty years... wouldn't a product like Felt be a step in the right direction?
What this app needs is a way to _design_ your own card, so there actually is a reason to have it digitally created. Think clipart + calligraphy with custom papers/stipling. Now you've got a real product.
Frankly, I think that most people would view this as disingenuous. The whole point of handwritten cards is that their supposed to be, uhhh, handwritten. A printout of something written seems sort of perfunctory, and isn't really better than simply sending a typed note. Indeed, the fact that one is attempting to forgo the work of writing a real card and instead using something like this will just dilute the sentiment of the gesture and appear lazy.