Ask PG: Publish story upvotes data to aid voting ring detection
Would it be possible to add one link to every story submitted to HN that goes to a page that lists all the people who upvoted a story that has been submitted?
Gaming the front page of HN (and other sites) has always been an issue, but techniques have gotten good enough where it is harder to detect. With that in mind and the skillset and hobbies of HNers in mind, it would be great to provide transparency so that data-science minded members of community can detect voting rings and provide their proofs to you.
It would be great if this page included: username, karma, timestamp_account_created, timestamp_upvoted and maybe the first three decimal dotted numbers of the IP address (or some other data point to help determine geographical or network proximity without sacrificing privacy)
(
13 comments
| 11 points
| on HN
)
I beleve PG has implimented a fairly sofisticated voting ring detection tool, I think I remember him talking about it before.
The knowledge that votes/flags are public may well change incentives, but I suspect the overall effect will be positive. That is people will be more thoughtful about what they vote up/down, rather than just voting for something because it's posted by a friend or flagging an article about a competitor.
Why should this become a place of witch-hunting?
You give no reason why it should be implemented other than that gaming sites has become more sophisticated.
That is not enough justification, especially since
-) i don't see clear signs for HN degrading in Quality
-) i am sure that pg is concerned about HN and has implemented some measurements to guarantee the high quality of this site for the future
No need for such drastic measurement just yet.
If the data is anonymized and there are no details published that can be used to identify the real user involved, it's no harm no foul. This wouldn't be about witch hunting but simply pattern matching.
We wouldn't be identifying witches but the act of witchery. We would never know who the witches were, only pg would. There would be no elements of shaming or individual people called out. This would be entirely ad hominem free.
Where's the evidence that these rings, if they exist, are having a detrimental enough effect on the frontpage to warrant something like this? Why is it so bad that PG, his fiddly algorithms and his staff of moderators can't deal with it?
Science should be a good enough reason to do it ;)
From what I have seen being on HN, the front page is usually of good quality and i m sure the voting ring detection mechanism is already decent.
It would be pretty neat to let the hackers on Hacker News see what kind of nefariousness can be sniffed out.