Re:Show HN - Side Project to Help You Decide What Craft Beer...
by dannowatts on Tuesday April 30, 2013 @11:22PM
(#5636277)
any substantial reason?
also, it's not about trust, it's about humor.
and good beer. might help if you drink a good beer and then go visit the site again :)
Re:Show HN - Side Project to Help You Decide What Craft Beer...
by timv on Wednesday May 01, 2013 @10:41PM
(#5642179)
Lack of transparency I guess.
If I enter a crap beer, say "heineken", I get told "no", which is fine.
If I enter random characters, say "rthjkejbfkel", I get told "no", which is not fine, because it means you are just saying no to anything that's not on your list.
So, if I enter a boutique beer that I like, say "Bluebottle" or anything from Mildura Brewery, I also get the "no", but I can't tell if it's because you're morons who don't appreciate good beer, or just ignorant about some excellent beers.
The only conclusion is I can draw is that you have a set of beers that you like, you'll say any other beer is crap (even if you've never tried it), and your suggestions are entirely opaque. I don't know why you like those beers, you're clearly not suggesting those beer based on any input I provided. That means is just a list of your preferred beers, with a front end that randomly selects a beer and an insult for me. Since I don't know you, or have any reason to trust your judgement in beer, there's no real reason to care.
Yes, it's about humor (although I don't find obscenities and insults to be particularly funny), but there's no evidence that it's actually about good beer - just beer that you happen to like with no explanation of why.
Re:Show HN - Side Project to Help You Decide What Craft Beer...
by dannowatts on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @04:38AM
(#5667069)
thanks for taking the time to write out a coherent answer and critique, i appreciate it. after reading through your thoughts, it's safe to say that you may not be the target demographic for the site!
Based on my 2 minutes of using it, that's a very firm no.
If I enter a crap beer, say "heineken", I get told "no", which is fine.
If I enter random characters, say "rthjkejbfkel", I get told "no", which is not fine, because it means you are just saying no to anything that's not on your list.
So, if I enter a boutique beer that I like, say "Bluebottle" or anything from Mildura Brewery, I also get the "no", but I can't tell if it's because you're morons who don't appreciate good beer, or just ignorant about some excellent beers.
The only conclusion is I can draw is that you have a set of beers that you like, you'll say any other beer is crap (even if you've never tried it), and your suggestions are entirely opaque. I don't know why you like those beers, you're clearly not suggesting those beer based on any input I provided. That means is just a list of your preferred beers, with a front end that randomly selects a beer and an insult for me. Since I don't know you, or have any reason to trust your judgement in beer, there's no real reason to care.
Yes, it's about humor (although I don't find obscenities and insults to be particularly funny), but there's no evidence that it's actually about good beer - just beer that you happen to like with no explanation of why.
I think that's almost certainly the case.