Re:Richer countries are happier than poorer ones. Richer fam...
by schiffern on Tuesday April 30, 2013 @02:34AM
(#5630714)
>why did bother creating the HDI if GDP/capita works just as well on most cases?
Because using GDP maximization to decide policy in those other cases results in lower overall happiness.
I would have no problem if economic policy-makers were content to merely correlate their decisions with increasing the GDP. Using it as the only end-goal, though, is foolish, and using it in those exceptional cases is, by utility maximization standards, evil.
But now we realize they are correlated, which begs the questions : are the parts about education, healthcare etc. within the HDI so unimportants ? (ie why did bother creating the HDI if GDP/capita works just as well on most cases)
But if works so well, shouldn't we also see diminishing marginal returns in GDP per capita ? (in neoclassical theory, diminishing marginal returns are everywhere !)
Some studies have added ad-hoc trigger points (up to $75k and you'll be happy, then not so much) but still from what I get it's a weird situation, and we are still learning important facts about the utility of money. It's quite interesting.
EDIT: Marking normative suggestions with regards to GDP per capita - I don't think I would, cause that's quite a bit off my league. There are different models, and many variables - not one simple solution.