News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple’s Jony Ive said to be bringing flat design to iOS 7 by ChrisNorstrom on Monday April 29, 2013 @06:03PM (#5629143)
Edit: No I'm not an Apple fan, I genuinely have a newfound love of flat ui (not block ui).

I've been very hard on Flat UI in the past (and still dislike the overdone blocky look) but I've decided to embrace it after realizing it's true purpose.

It's NOT to destroy skeuomorphism. It's to destroy "forced focus design" in favor of "distraction free design". In the past we used gradients to aim the eyes towards a direction, shadows to make elements pop out of the page at a viewer, overly rounded corners to seem friendlier to the viewer, etc... We styled elements like this so we could draw attention to certain things and away from others. The same way people wear certain clothing to stand out or fade in with the crowd.

However, in this era of instant gratification online property owners not only realized that content is king but that there's too much shit to do and not enough time to do it. They need to give the viewer what they want and give it to as quickly as possible. Confusion breads negative feelings and pissed off viewers leave and don't return. So pages became lighter, more minimal, and lost unnecessary elements, and so designers adjusted to this.

By getting rid of the un-needed information on a page we no longer have to draw attention to one thing and away from the other because everything on the page is important. If it wasn't, it shouldn't be there in there in the first place. The buttons don't all need to have massive rounded corners and huge shadows because they're no longer lost in a sea of text and ads. They're easy to spot.

This is why you'll notice a lot of Flat UI sites are a lot more minimal than usual.

The Flat UI that I HATE is the blocky kind. Minecraft / 8-bit / designer out of college / what the hell's an a/b test inspired extreme flat ui. The kind where you don't know if that's a header with a colored background or a clickable button. The flat ui where everything on the site is so white white white you'd think the owners were clansman. That crap I hate. And it's only a few dozen A/B tests away from disappearing off of prominent sites.

I don't think this is "just a fad" anymore. There's a reason big companies are switching to it. Microsoft, Apple, Google. They're not stupid. They run A/B tests. They're not going to sacrifice market share, page views, usability, ease-of-use, and their bottom line just to blindly follow a design fad. That's just an insult to them. To say all Flat UI is backwards while the internet's biggest companies convert to it just goes to show how delusional and unknowledgeable we (especially I) can be. I apologize for my past remarks.

Re:Apple’s Jony Ive said to be bringing flat design to iOS 7 by kyro on Monday April 29, 2013 @06:15PM (#5629212)
I personally think it's just the in-style at the moment. It's different than what we're used to, barebones, and uses vibrant colors -- the antithesis of recent popular styles. Some seasons blacks and grays and navies are in, other seasons women like wearing greens and oranges and yellows. UX-wise, though, flat has more problems, but people might not care because it looks so fresh.
Re:Apple’s Jony Ive said to be bringing flat design to iOS 7 by magic_haze on Monday April 29, 2013 @06:31PM (#5629295)
Agreed, it'll probably settle down in a few seasons to something moderate (i.e., neither the garishness of apple's calendar, nor the usability nightmare of the WP8 app on windows.) I just wish we won't forget the lessons of these experiments, but most likely we'll just be reinventing the whole thing again and again. (Recent example: the horrible 90's emoticons craze is back in messaging apps these days, except they're now higher resolution and are called 'stickers'.)
Re:Apple’s Jony Ive said to be bringing flat design to iOS 7 by alex_doom on Monday April 29, 2013 @06:54PM (#5629396)
Do you mean Emoji? I've never heard it called stickers.
Re:Apple’s Jony Ive said to be bringing flat design to iOS 7 by robgough on Monday April 29, 2013 @07:25PM (#5629519)
Stickers is the name Facebook are giving to their version...

http://newsroom.fb.com/News/604/Messaging-updates-for-iPhone...

Re:Apple’s Jony Ive said to be bringing flat design to iOS 7 by guptaneil on Monday April 29, 2013 @07:30PM (#5629537)
Facebook, Path, MessageMe, and more call it stickers to differentiate from emoji. Stickers are generally larger and can be used on their own, while emoji are used with other text.
Re:Apple’s Jony Ive said to be bringing flat design to iOS 7 by gfodor on Monday April 29, 2013 @06:45PM (#5629354)
I don't buy it. If your design philosophy is rooted in "this time is different" then it's a pretty shallow design philosophy.

In other words, debates about "flat UI" vs "skeumorphism" (which is a false dichotomy imho, but I digress) should not be based upon things like "this era of instant gratification", it should be based upon how well the design serves the purpose of all design: effective and enjoyable use by humans.

The reason skeumorphism exists as an idea is not because it is used to draw the eye to something, it's to create affordances to the user by leveraging their past experiences. This can range anywhere from "this sticks out on the page and can be pushed" to "this reminds me of my real desk calendar."

Insofar as the Flat UI concept neglects to create these natural affordances it fails. The only argument one can make that draws upon the current status quo to defend it is if the world has moved on so fast that natural affordances created by depth and shadow can now be made just as effectively to most people by drawing a colored square instead. I'm skeptical that this is true, since three dimensional vision is pretty core to the human experience and human biology.

I think what we'll see from Apple will not be an abandonment of skeumorphism in general but instead (in typical Ives fashion) a distilling of it down to its core. Expect depth and shadow, but with a laser-like focus towards using it to create affordances instead of add unnecessary flare. Expect its use to be toned down both in prevalence and also in degree. The cliched example of the leather nav bar has never served any real purpose wrt affordances, so I don't think Apple will be clinging too tightly to it.

Re:Apple’s Jony Ive said to be bringing flat design to iOS 7 by melloclello on Monday April 29, 2013 @09:05PM (#5629876)
I would say that non-flat design isn't for "aiming the eyes" - drop shadows, bevels, and gradients help things to stand out and communicate affordance in a way that's immediately compatible with the human visual cortex. Flat design is a constrained form - it's like saying you'll paint a painting with only two colours, or write a song with only two notes.

Keep in mind that your visual cortex responds more to difference in colours and spatial frequencies more so than it does to flat expanses of colour. Things like drop shadows and borders add much-needed high-frequency acutance [1] at the edges of shapes, which helps with object recognition.

You see this all the time in the real world - take a look at the logo on these cans [2] and note the white border surrounded by the black border. Going from the base colour like this, all the way to white and then back to black effectively saturates the spatial frequencies at the edge of the shape and forces it to stand out from the background - I'm holding one of these cans in my hand right now and boy oh boy does that logo ever pop.

You see the similar techniques around all the time - look at the text labels on Google Maps, or the black borders around video subtitles. Similarly, see the gradient and drop shadows on the icons on an iPhone home screen - those are there to make them visually recognisable as objects, as opposed to rounded rectangles.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acutance

[2] http://i.imgur.com/WWRDsiE.jpg

Edit: further demonstrations of your visual cortex responding to differentials:

TEMPORAL: http://imgur.com/iqMFv5z.gif

If you stare at the center cross long enough, your retina fatigues and the pink dots start to disappear. Likewise, the rotating absence of a dot is replaced by green.

SPATIAL: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/0a/HermannGr...

The sharp spatial frequencies (unlike anything you would find in nature), aligned at right angles to one another interfere with one another so strongly that you start to see dots at the grid intersections (some may find this stronger than others, I sometimes get this effect from the Windows 8 homescreen, for chrissakes).

Re:Apple’s Jony Ive said to be bringing flat design to iOS 7 by crucialfelix on Monday April 29, 2013 @06:56PM (#5629408)
I don't think the appeal is in the minimalism or the lack of visual garnishes. It's that these panes and quickly changing elements are fast and they appear thin, lightweight and therefor emphasize the speed. You can see the light glowing through the panel. It's energizing.

Metal or drop shadow or physical looking sliders imply solidity and weight. That was a desired thing in the era when we were getting used to screen interfaces. But metal implies that it doesn't move fast. You can't replace an interface with a new modal one that quickly or it looks unreal and weird, like you are flinging metal cabinetry around !

Re:Apple’s Jony Ive said to be bringing flat design to iOS 7 by lurker14 on Monday April 29, 2013 @06:44PM (#5629348)
> I've been very hard on Flat UI in the past (and still dislike extreme Flat UI) but I've decided to embrace it after--

--after Apple declared it to be in style.

No, that's not what you meant, but it rings so true in the tech buzzosphere.

Re:Apple’s Jony Ive said to be bringing flat design to iOS 7 by ChrisNorstrom on Monday April 29, 2013 @07:13PM (#5629471)
Poor guy, I don't think they should have downvoted you. Have an upvote. Btw, I can't stand Apple. Not my style, not my thing. Tried to convert several times and went straight back to Windows. I hate the whole authoritative cult like brand.

My decision is based on the new flat UI I've seen already working on Google's Gmail and YouTube properties as well as Microsoft's. They're not perfect but they're definitely heading in a better direction with flat ui. If I recall, Microsoft sort of started it with the Windows Metro look, then Google really sealed the deal by converting gmail and youtube into flat ui sites.

Re:Apple’s Jony Ive said to be bringing flat design to iOS 7 by m_mueller on Monday April 29, 2013 @09:19PM (#5629915)
It's interesting that you consider YouTube a positive example. During their flat transition they seem to have thrown out many features that I consider important for the platform. As an example, I lately can't figure out anymore how to jump from a video to 'more from this user'. They splat their semi useful recommendation everywhere instead.
Re:Apple’s Jony Ive said to be bringing flat design to iOS 7 by atechnerd on Monday April 29, 2013 @07:48PM (#5629601)
The flat look in gmail does seem to take out a lot of the visual noise.

Here's metro influence gone awry: http://www.pepsi.com/en-us/d

It's pretty close to a flat look, but I still notice some subtle gradients going on. But talk about tile explosion!