Agreed. Seems a bit disingenuous to espouse the virtues of 'open source community' and putting yourself at the other end of the spectrum with 'evil' Facebook, then actually engaging in hat passing. Not dissing your efforts or your product (looks cool), but leave the colorful, evocative terms like 'open source' to the side next time and be honest about your marketing exercise intentions.
Re:Ghost: The Future of Blogging (Node.js)
by nobodysfool on Monday April 29, 2013 @11:55AM
(#5626941)
Yea, it looks okay, it's pretty much bootstrap with a black and white theme. The 'markdown live preview' seems neat, but it's nothing that hasn't been done before. The dashboard looks neat, but it's obviously not finished yet, and perhaps that's why they need money. Responsive layout isn't anything too difficult to implement for a blog. It looks like he did pay someone to make the corporate site, or spent a bit of time on it, but yeah, this is nothing special. It is MIT licensed, so in theory, they could take 'poet' (also MIT licensed) and release it themselves and take investors money.
Re:Ghost: The Future of Blogging (Node.js)
by timruffles on Monday April 29, 2013 @12:13PM
(#5627054)
Why? Open Source just means the source is open. There's nothing to say it can't be paid for up front, or even that the binaries are free.
I like this model far more than the one that depends on declaring information to be property. In fact, I hope (and largely expect) it will become the predominant means of getting developers paid.
Re:Ghost: The Future of Blogging (Node.js)
by thatthatis on Monday April 29, 2013 @11:35AM
(#5626829)
I don't think you can build a vibrant community if you use the hostage model. Without a community, it would be hard for an OSS project to stay relevant for very long.
Stuff takes time to make, and time costs money unless you are independently wealthy or have a trust fund.
This looks gorgeous, but many of these features are non-trivial to implement.
Re:Ghost: The Future of Blogging (Node.js)
by mrgoldenbrown on Monday April 29, 2013 @11:03PM
(#5630208)
It's fine to ask for money, but they could solicit money without declaring themselves open source yet, with a promise to do so in the future, or they could actually release the source now, and continue to solicit money. Instead they are claiming to already be open source but not actually opening anything. I think that's what got people a little put off.
Or have an enterprise that allows workers to devote some part of their daily duty to support/build it...
Re:Ghost: The Future of Blogging (Node.js)
by mrgoldenbrown on Monday April 29, 2013 @11:08PM
(#5630219)
The bait and switch is what got me too. I don't see the need for giving us the run around. It would be easy to be up front about what's going on. Changing a few sentences from present tense to future tense would go a long way.
Possibly my ire was raised a bit further by the fact that I found that out in what seemed a slightly bait and switch-y way - "Try this!" click "Maybe later if you pay us!" Hmmmm.
Those gripes aside, it looks pretty.