News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Founders: Don't Forget to Sell The Dream by brandnewlow on Sunday April 28, 2013 @07:08PM (#5623194)
Please stop and consider taking some time away from HN.

The stories posted here clearly anger and upset you. This comment you just posted is a strawman argument and you posted a variant of it the other day in another thread, and another variant of it in another thread before that and....you've been posting variants of it on HN almost daily for months now.

As a founder, my ears always perk up with I find pointed criticism of founders on HN. I read carefully to see if there's any ideas or advice I can come away with. But for months now, every time there's been really aggressive criticism of founders on HN, the comment always turns out to be written by you. And it's always the same complaint or variant on it every time. It's gotten to the point where I have to screen comment threads ahead of time in case you've posted already.

Is it really healthy to keep returning to a well you find so poisonous? Jason wrote a well-intended article here and you're using it to post your same ideas for the 10th time this month. Is that fair to him? Is that fair to Hacker News readers?

Take some time off. Find things that excite you, captivate you, and make you feel joyful to be live. VC-istan is clearly not a place you want to spend time in, so go explore and find a better place.

Re:Founders: Don't Forget to Sell The Dream by michaelochurch on Sunday April 28, 2013 @07:32PM (#5623299)
I feel like my work isn't done. The truth needs to be told, and unfortunately, very few people have the courage to tell it, especially under their real names.

No, I don't dislike all founders or VCs obviously. I just hate most of the ones I've interacted with, and I'm shocked by the number of people who've had similarly horrible experiences. When I left my last startup after being asked to do something horribly unethical, in March 2012, I thought I'd been extremely unlucky. I thought my experience was a 1-in-10,000 case of bad luck. As I poked around, though, I realized that horrible experiences are the norm in VC-istan. People just don't talk about it.

Why the fuck aren't they speaking up? Why aren't they exposing unethical people and companies? Why are people so terrified of ex-bosses that they refuse to tell the truth so the horrible founders can fail and some good ones can step in?

I've managed to put cracks in the image of VC-istan. My job is to make those cracks bigger so some light can get through. At least some of the climate of anger that's been on Hacker News for the past few months is something I've started. Good for me. I'm starting to contribute. Courage is in rare supply in our industry; we tend to bend over and take it when our masters screw us. Well, at least I will fucking speak up.

So, I've also worked in finance. As an industry, it has an image problem. To get smart people, it has to pay. So it does. Most of the work isn't terribly interesting, but the pay is good and the people are actually a lot more decent than in VC-istan. If you're good, they'll treat you well. In general, financial firms are a lot better, ethically speaking, than VC-istan.

If we can bring VC-istan's image in line with what it actually is, then they'll have to (like finance) start treating engineers better if they want to get talent, and the bad startups will die out, making room for good ones.

Re:Founders: Don't Forget to Sell The Dream by brandnewlow on Sunday April 28, 2013 @10:41PM (#5623799)
This post is problematic on several levels.

1. You call founders and VCs rapists and slaveowners. "We tend to bend over and take it when our masters screw us." Do you know founders who literally own their employees? Do you know founders who have literally raped their employees? Of course not. You're trying to score points through lazy writing. Citation needed.

2. You state that developers lack courage. Citation needed.

3. You spend most of the comment writing in the first person singular and then switch to the first person plural in the last paragraph as a rhetorical trick to elicit a sense of solidarity in the reader. This is manipulative.

4. You state that you had a bad experience about a year ago and say that you thought it was a 1-in-10,000 case, but then after you "poked around" you found out it was "the norm", i.e. 1-in-1. This is a ludicrous statement. How can you know what the norm is after poking around? Did you talk to 100 people? The other 9,999? There are actual people out there conducting surveys on things like this. Are you one of them? Citation needed.

You are not contributing. You are not doing a job. You are fearmongering, aggressively and perniciously.

Certainly there are bad actors and bad players in "tech". But simply stating that "horrible experiences are the norm" over and over and over again does not make it true. It's lazy writing.

Re:Founders: Don't Forget to Sell The Dream by textminer on Sunday April 28, 2013 @08:27PM (#5623468)
I find your comments to be spectacularly useful. I'm a twenty something machine learning developer with a functional bent and high expectations for rewarding stimulation in VC-land, and you've recapitulated many of my own thoughts and conclusions spectacularly well. Would you mind if I bent your ear about a dilemma over private channels?
Re:Founders: Don't Forget to Sell The Dream by jamesaguilar on Sunday April 28, 2013 @08:33PM (#5623487)
You might be better off asking someone who has accomplished more than blog posts and hn comments. Sounding like you know what you're talking about and actually knowing it are not always the same. Results are often a better signal of the latter. Just my 2c.
Re:Founders: Don't Forget to Sell The Dream by nitrogen on Sunday April 28, 2013 @09:34PM (#5623640)
On the other hand, only talking to those who have been wildly successful, or giving their advice more weight, sounds like a great way to get trapped by confirmation and survivorship bias.
Re:Founders: Don't Forget to Sell The Dream by jamesaguilar on Sunday April 28, 2013 @09:39PM (#5623649)
Good point. But if I were looking for an unsuccessful person to get advice from, I'd pick someone who looked within for mistakes/opportunities for improvement, rather than exclusively blaming external factors.
Re:Founders: Don't Forget to Sell The Dream by nitrogen on Sunday April 28, 2013 @11:56PM (#5623985)
Even if they are largely external, we can't say that michaelochurch hasn't been providing suggestions for improvement. His overall message doesn't strike me as complaining just to complain, even if some of his individual posts are a bit over the top.
Re:Founders: Don't Forget to Sell The Dream by jamesaguilar on Monday April 29, 2013 @12:00AM (#5623995)
His overall message is how companies and management can improve -- advice for a position he's never been in and has no experience with. If he's said things that represent a serious acknowledgement of his own shortcomings as an employee -- i.e. a frank discussion of why such a high proportion of his employment experiences have been bad compared to typical HNers or engineers -- I'm not aware of them. He seems to be fairly self-congratulatory on that front, which is at odds with the results so far.
Re:Founders: Don't Forget to Sell The Dream by michaelochurch on Monday April 29, 2013 @12:38AM (#5624116)
I checked your profile. One of those. Still butthurt that I exposed calibration scores and embarrassed "your" company?

His overall message is how companies and management can improve -- advice for a position he's never been in and has no experience with.

Wait, so watching idiots incinerate hundreds of millions, if not billions, of dollars of value through horrible business decisions when I could have done their jobs better at 17 is not direct experience?

I'm good at learning from failures-- my own (I've made plenty of mistakes, despite your claim that I don't acknowledge error on my part) and other peoples'.

a frank discussion of why such a high proportion of his employment experiences have been bad compared to typical HNers or engineers

What has astonished me is to learn that my horrible experiences are not atypical. I thought I was the only person to be screwed over so badly, and found out that there are hundreds of people with similar stories.

I won't claim that it's the norm, but it's not shockingly rare. People just don't fucking admit to these experience because they internalize their losses when the reality is that most people have shitty careers not because they are human garbage (as their bosses want them to think) but simply because they have been lied-to, exploited, and fucking robbed blind by their extortionist, criminal managers who have demolished their careers through bad work allocation and political malfeasance.

I wouldn't put myself so far out there on these issues if I hadn't realized that there's a whole corrupt system whose malignancies are underreported. If it was just me having bad experiences, I wouldn't go out there and point out how awful it is. Too embarrassing, no point. Unfortunately, the abuses of talent by the well-connected criminals are commonplace and it's time to fight back. Technology is our territory by rights and we should take it back from those assholes.

Re:Founders: Don't Forget to Sell The Dream by jamesaguilar on Monday April 29, 2013 @01:33AM (#5624256)
> butthurt

I'd be lying if I claimed you did not spark my interest with your episode at my workplace. However, I am in no way upset about it, any more than I'd be upset by one of those YouTube fail videos. I was actually one of the ones who tried to help you. So, let's stick to discussion of my actual points. If I made untrue claims, it's enough to point them out, right?

Reiterating my primary point, in case it has been lost in the back-and-forth: if your approach leads to satisfaction, success, wealth, fame, or any other thing an ordinary person wants, I'd love to see some evidence of it. Does any exist? Failing evidence, I advise a novice to consider your words with a strong degree of skepticism, and to take into account your personal track record. This is healthy, no?

> so watching idiots ... [fail where] I could have done better at 17

You are like a walking, talking paragon of the Dunning-Kreuger effect. If you could do better, do it. I'd be surprised, but surprise is an emotion rationalists welcome. If I see some evidence of your extraordinary claims [1], I'll update.

And, no, backseat CEO-ing does not count as experience. Come on, that much must be obvious.

> not atypical

Hard to say if you're falling to selection bias or me. You are highly atypical among the people I know or have heard of, and your comments certainly stand out as unusual on this site.

> Technology is our territory

It is the territory of people who make things, or who lead makers, as it has always been. People who do neither of those are mere onlookers.

[1] http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Extraordinary_claims_require_ex...

Re:Founders: Don't Forget to Sell The Dream by michaelochurch on Monday April 29, 2013 @07:44AM (#5625477)
I tried to read your reply and my brain threw this:

   internet.util.MindBlownException
   Caused by: DoucheOverloadException
       at lowSignalSnark(your.post:9)
   Caused by: MoronDoesntUnderstandDunningKrugerError
       at yabberYabber(your.post:11)
Re:Founders: Don't Forget to Sell The Dream by jamesaguilar on Monday April 29, 2013 @09:55AM (#5626122)
In other words, you have no salient objections to what I've said. Got it.
Re:Founders: Don't Forget to Sell The Dream by oz on Sunday April 28, 2013 @08:40PM (#5623506)
I've spoken with MOC over private channels, and he's * stunningly* helpful.
Re:Founders: Don't Forget to Sell The Dream by textminer on Sunday April 28, 2013 @08:34PM (#5623489)
(Just in case my comment sounded parodic because of my self-description, or contrarian because of your call for public bravery, it wasn't meant to be either.)
Re:Founders: Don't Forget to Sell The Dream by michaelochurch on Sunday April 28, 2013 @08:47PM (#5623528)
Go for it. I'm michael.o.church at gmail.
Re:Founders: Don't Forget to Sell The Dream by mindcrime on Sunday April 28, 2013 @08:58PM (#5623555)
FWIW, I enjoy your posts very much as well. I don't always agree with everything you say, but I often agree with much of it. And even where I disagree, it's where I sometimes think you are guilty of over-generalizing.

Keep it up. The world needs more people who are willing to shed the light on unpopular truths, speak their minds, and say things most other people won't say.

Re:Founders: Don't Forget to Sell The Dream by justkelly_ on Tuesday April 30, 2013 @02:10AM (#5630660)
That's michaelochurch's game, though. Step 1. Experience a personal setback. Step 2. Make sure you never ever ever ever take any accountability for said experience. It's never michaelochurch's fault, he's been dealt such a bad hand, it's all because of those ASSHOLES. Everything bad that happens to him is someone else's fault. He's just a visionary, man, downtrodden because corporate blah blah blah blah... Step 3. Make absurd, mostly-untrue generalizations and nonsensically rant them all over HN. I mean, who cares if a few lies (FACT) are thrown in there, as long as they're about a big powerful company like Google? STICK IT TO THE MAN, MAN