Re:'Flat design'-inspired Google Maps using the API
by ryanmerket on Sunday April 28, 2013 @05:05PM
(#5622768)
This. Flat design may look 'cleaner' but that doesn't mean 'easier to use'. I echo your usability findings -- usability tests are showing flat design is much harder to use.
Flat design basically gets rid of all this. It hasn't fared well in my own user studies. Users tend not to hit a button if it is just a flat icon tucked in a corner with nothing to clue them in that they should be hitting it or what it does. You are generally stuck in the first revision to put a tutorial overlay with a big arrow and text the first time the user comes to the screen.
The lack of text in this so you can't tell what any street is? That's very flat UI style. They hate text that clutters up their designs and tells people what things actually do. Proponents of flat design generally base their decision on the fact that it looks better to graphics designers looking at the app (instead of using it).