This whole incident serves to remind me that many people apparently have no idea that folk music exists. Yes, people routinely spend tens of thousands of hours mastering multiple musical instruments in order to be able to play for themselves, for their family and friends, and for random passers-by for free. Yes, folk musicians sometimes get paid to play, but can also be expected to be found jamming away in hallways, tents, parking lots and living rooms with fellow musicians and fans - there is no real line between a musician and a fan. And the privilege of jamming along with one of your musical idols is not something one expects to be paid for; indeed, a relatively modern innovation in folk and bluegrass is the formal "music camp", where the students pay for this privilege.
Re:Zach Braff, Amanda Palmer, and the New 90-9-1 Rule
by makomk on Sunday April 28, 2013 @09:59AM
(#5621238)
I seem to recall that the Amanda Palmer backlash less to do with her being popular and more to do with her raising a huge sum of money for an album and tour, then expecting background musicians to work for free because she was popular - and that was just the latest in a line of ethically dubious things she's done.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Zach Braff, Amanda Palmer, and the New 90-9-1 Rule
by tptacek on Sunday April 28, 2013 @10:53AM
(#5621408)
The story I read said that she invited local musicians who happened to be fans on stage with her.
Re:Zach Braff, Amanda Palmer, and the New 90-9-1 Rule
by tehwebguy on Sunday April 28, 2013 @11:07AM
(#5621459)
Correct, which is insanely cool. It's like a design contest - if an organization crowdsources all of their design work it is tacky and offensive, but having a rare or occasional contest is a great way to get talented fans involved.
Re:Zach Braff, Amanda Palmer, and the New 90-9-1 Rule
by veridies on Sunday April 28, 2013 @12:43PM
(#5621796)
Except it wasn't an amateur contest, or even a contest; they just chose the best professional musicians they could to back them up.
Re:Zach Braff, Amanda Palmer, and the New 90-9-1 Rule
by decklin on Monday April 29, 2013 @10:06AM
(#5626178)
No, she hired and paid a band of professional musicians, who toured with her. She also invited fans in each city to play with them on stage.
Re:Zach Braff, Amanda Palmer, and the New 90-9-1 Rule
by mechanical_fish on Monday April 29, 2013 @11:10AM
(#5626630)
A friend of ours is a very talented fiddle player and she got invited to jam with Amanda on stage. She was thrilled, naturally.