News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MBA - good or bad for a tech start-up? by ajiang on Friday April 26, 2013 @03:59PM (#5615087)
I wouldn't phrase it as a question of Good vs. Bad, but rather Necessary vs. Unnecessary.

For me, it's a return-on-investment question, whether the 2 years and $100k+ in tuition would advance my ambitions more than 2 years of building and $100k that could go towards self-funding.

Re:MBA - good or bad for a tech start-up? by up_and_up on Friday April 26, 2013 @04:21PM (#5615211)
> $100k that could go towards self-funding

This is not really accurate. The 100K for the MBA will likely come from financial aid which can be paid over time, maybe 6-10 years. Thus it is generally not paid with cash on hand.

At the same time there is no $100k financial aid to start a company. Sometimes you can find family money or smaller personal loans, but 100K for a biz is much harder to come by and not the same as 100K of Gov backed financial aid.

This is apples and oranges here...

That being said, your main point re ROI stands..

Re:MBA - good or bad for a tech start-up? by tptacek on Friday April 26, 2013 @04:28PM (#5615251)
The $100k of personal debt you take on to obtain an MBA is worse than startup funding: aside from the fact that most startup funding is based on equity and is never repaid, that "government backed financial aid" isn't dischargeable in bankruptcy; you are more or less going to have to pay it back no matter what.
Re:MBA - good or bad for a tech start-up? by mesozoic on Friday April 26, 2013 @06:35PM (#5615892)
That is true the terms are worse. If you can get seed funding go for it. The other thing an MBA gives you though is a pretty soft landing pad if your startup fails.
Re:MBA - good or bad for a tech start-up? by tptacek on Friday April 26, 2013 @10:42PM (#5616598)
Disagree! Lots of people have MBAs. It's not an effective differentiator. A smart, ambitious engineer can do most of the jobs an MBA normally qualifies for, so MBAs have that source of competition too. Meanwhile: your landing includes $100k of non-disposable debt.

A couple years ago, I worked for a UMich MBA in a product marketing role. I remember hearing about how MBA's weren't worth getting unless you got one from a top school. But that was years ago. In 2013, even if you can pick one up from Wharton, you're still probably going to end up worse-off unless you manage to parlay the degree into a role in finance.

Don't get an MBA.

Re:MBA - good or bad for a tech start-up? by comatose_kid on Friday April 26, 2013 @04:02PM (#5615102)
Great point. I just wanted to counter the prevailing wisdom that an MBA is not worthwhile & show how my perceptions of it changed over time.

ROI: Most choices result in opportunity cost - expense and time were considerations, but the skills gained will stay with me for life.