I think something about the high resolution makes flat design (which is really just a derivative of 20th century modernist design) somehow feel ultra-clean. There's suddenly a new depth to the minimalism. It stands out more against 3D elements. It's much like how Swiss Design feels very different on paper vs. on a screen.
Subtle texture and animation on a retina display can recreate the latter effect to some extent.
So I'm really conflicted with this retina trend and how designers are (not) utilizing it. I don't think information density should increase, but certainly more complex artifacts could be used rather than these simplistic ones.