News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lessons In Survival - why elite military forces bounce ba... by gaius on Tuesday April 14, 2009 @04:59AM (#561207)
It's all about unit cohesion. The psychology of it is well-understood. People are afraid of failing so are reluctant to push their limits and expose themselves to criticism from their peers. By putting everyone through an ordeal together, everyone sees everyone else suffering, that barrier is broken down. The benefits of this type of training go way beyond the military.
Re:Lessons In Survival - why elite military forces bounce ba... by chriskelley on Tuesday April 14, 2009 @05:12AM (#561213)
Put me with a perfect stranger and give us 80 minutes on the rugby pitch together and it's mind-blowing how fast a deep friendship can form.
Re:Lessons In Survival - why elite military forces bounce ba... by gaius on Tuesday April 14, 2009 @06:04AM (#561249)
Yeah, strip everyone down to the basics, no pretences, no bullshit, and we're all basically the same. Well, that's not true. There are those who are willing to do this and those that aren't.
Re:Lessons In Survival - why elite military forces bounce ba... by andyjenn on Tuesday April 14, 2009 @09:24AM (#561414)
Not always, although I know where you are coming from. Pretty soon you can find out whether they're someone you can "go over the trenches" with, no matter what size they might look.
Re:Lessons In Survival - why elite military forces bounce ba... by anamax on Tuesday April 14, 2009 @10:42AM (#561547)
Sports both build character and reveal it.
Re:Lessons In Survival - why elite military forces bounce ba... by dejb on Tuesday April 14, 2009 @08:33AM (#561349)
I wonder whether the benefits are for those being trained or those doing the training. It seems to me the greatest trick of waging war is to convince people to put their lives at risk against an enemy that did not originally threaten them. Some people might refer to this phenomena as brain washing.
Re:Lessons In Survival - why elite military forces bounce ba... by scott_s on Tuesday April 14, 2009 @10:17AM (#561503)
Actually, the greatest trick of waging war is to convince people to kill other people, and that's done with plain ol' operant conditioning: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operant_conditioning

Read "On Killing: The Psychological Cost of Learning to Kill in War and Society." The author, Dave Grossman, is an Army Ranger and a Psychology professor at West Point. He lays down an argument that most people have a strong, instinctual resistance to killing. In WWI, only about 20% on the front lines even fired their weapons. That rose during WWII and Korea until during Vietnam, it was closer to 95%. He attributes the change to modern training methods which are basically operant conditioning.

(He also has fascinating interviews with veterans about their experiences. But the book sometimes feels like someone's dissertation, and at the end, he tries to make the same claim with violent media, which I don't think holds. Watching something is very different from doing something.)

Re:Lessons In Survival - why elite military forces bounce ba... by qazwsxedc on Tuesday April 14, 2009 @12:57PM (#561804)
It improved with attempts to dehumanise the enemy (Germans -> krauts -> Gooks) and the distance with which you face them (hand-hand in a trench -> carpet bombing of jungle) It has swung back the other way with soldiers have a live view of the target in a sight/TV picture - the proportion of willing to kill has reduced.
Re:Lessons In Survival - why elite military forces bounce ba... by scott_s on Tuesday April 14, 2009 @12:59PM (#561807)
Grossman covers this in his book. He covers much more than I can summarize in a HN post, so check it out if the subject interests you.
Re:Lessons In Survival - why elite military forces bounce ba... by gaius on Tuesday April 14, 2009 @01:22PM (#561858)
the proportion of willing to kill has reduced

Citation?

Re:Lessons In Survival - why elite military forces bounce ba... by Radix on Tuesday April 14, 2009 @01:15PM (#561843)
I think it holds to a point. Watching something allows you to think it, and thinking something can take you about half way.

Many people couldn't couldn't surgically cut someone open, too squemish, but after watching it done they could at least think it.

Re:Lessons In Survival - why elite military forces bounce ba... by scott_s on Tuesday April 14, 2009 @02:27PM (#561971)
I agree it can help to desensitize, but Grossman was using it to explain the rise in violence during the '90s.

But I think there is a difference to being desensitized to media violence and being desensitized to real violence that happens in front of your face.

Re:Lessons In Survival - why elite military forces bounce ba... by run4yourlives on Tuesday April 14, 2009 @03:28PM (#562128)
If modern training methods can be shown to quantitatively effect killing ratios, as he relates, I'm not sure why it is such a stretch to believe that continual bombardment of imagery or role playing (i.e. video games) would not have the same - although perhaps lessor - effect.

I realize this is an uncomfortable theory for many of us who believe we are masters of our environment, but it holds water.

You are right though, there is a difference between media and reality. The problem is that it doesn't manifest until after both situations have occurred. Ergo PTSD.

Post media saturation but pre-real life drama is a very unstable time for individuals, as the likelihood that they will confuse the media outcomes for the real ones is the highest. I think this is essentially Grossman's point, and I don't find it that far fetched.

Your environment affects you, whether you choose to believe it does or not. (Note that this is not to suggest that the same environment affects people in the same way).

Re:Lessons In Survival - why elite military forces bounce ba... by scott_s on Tuesday April 14, 2009 @04:00PM (#562214)
The reason I draw the distinction is because modern training methods stress shooting an actual gun in certain circumstances. I think the fact that the training involves the physical act of shooting a real gun is important. This means that the only difference between training and combat is the stress level and what the solder is shooting at.

That's operant conditioning. If you remove a physical gun and replace it with a virtual gun, perhaps some operant conditioning can take place, but I doubt it will be enough to overcome our disinclination to kill another person. (I know the military actually use FPSes for training in some circumstances - but I think it's used more for communication practice than anything else, and it's used in combination with modern training methods.) The reason I stress virtual versus physical is that you want training to be as close to reality to get the desired behavior.

If you remove participant action completely, such as passively watching a movie, then I think you've lost operant conditioning entirely. Grossman spends much of the book arguing that humans' instinct not to kill other people is so large that we need operant conditioning to overcome it. He submits that the untrained combatant will sometimes literally die instead of firing their weapon. He ignores this argument at the end of the book.

Re:Lessons In Survival - why elite military forces bounce ba... by run4yourlives on Tuesday April 14, 2009 @05:58PM (#562442)
but I doubt it will be enough to overcome our disinclination to kill another person

Clearly it isn't, in most cases. But then again, soldiers don't go around arbitrarily killing people either. The fact that the conditioning exists has little to do with whether or not it is exercised.

I think for certain individuals, simply watching the actions of others is enough to alter behaviour. As such, watching continuous murders may indeed be enough to alter behaviour for a select group of outliers in dramatic ways.

The conditioning norm remains subconscious until summoned, which would mean that for most of us, it would never be used. Extremely stressful situations would of course trigger the reaction - and this would fit with the crazed gunman incidents that seem so prevalent these days (historically, gunmen tended to have military experience, interesting side note).

untrained combatant will sometimes literally die instead of firing their weapon

I think he was using historical information to make this observation. It seems obvious to me however that most modern North Americans are not longer subject to this "limitation". Fighting back pirates is certainly a good supporter of this, and seems to lend some support to his point.

Re:Lessons In Survival - why elite military forces bounce ba... by gaius on Tuesday April 14, 2009 @09:11AM (#561397)
Cops, paramedics and firefighters all put their lives at risk going into situations that did not originally threaten them. Yet no-one would describe them as "brainwashed".
Re:Lessons In Survival - why elite military forces bounce ba... by dejb on Tuesday April 14, 2009 @10:15AM (#561499)
There is a certain threshold of dangerous and selfless action that defies ordinary logic. In the cases of direct and unambiguous help to others it is called heroism. In cases where the action causes harm to some parties the definition is less clear. In the worst cases it is referred to as terrorism. Either way the readiness to face mortal danger can be used for both good and evil. Whether it represents brainwashing however is a different question.
Re:Lessons In Survival - why elite military forces bounce ba... by run4yourlives on Tuesday April 14, 2009 @03:36PM (#562151)
dejb, I'm going to take a wild guess and say that you haven't actually been exposed to any form of military training, have you?

While you may feel this to be irrelevant, I can assure you that you aren't quite able to grasp the nuances and evolved thinking behind this type of "performance under stress" training unless you have experienced it firsthand. Being an observer isn't good enough.

It's "brainwashing" only in as much as all other forms of teaching are brainwashing. Which is to say that it is not.

Re:Lessons In Survival - why elite military forces bounce ba... by dejb on Tuesday April 14, 2009 @07:54PM (#562616)
> While you may feel this to be irrelevant

I actually think it is quite relevant. If I'm right then you have been to some extent brainwashed into the thinking that the training is reasonable. Your response makes sense if you had been brainwashed or if you hadn't. Of course this doesn't prove anything either way.

The point is that the proper identification of brainwashing is always going to come from an external observer. To me the process I have heard described of 'breaking someone down and then building them up again' is the definition of brainwashing.

Re:Lessons In Survival - why elite military forces bounce ba... by run4yourlives on Tuesday April 14, 2009 @08:11PM (#562637)
You make a valid point.

I think where we differ is in our definition of what constitutes "brainwashing".

Re:Lessons In Survival - why elite military forces bounce ba... by greyboy on Tuesday April 14, 2009 @11:40AM (#561648)
That makes it sound rather subjective, then.
Re:Lessons In Survival - why elite military forces bounce ba... by Tangurena on Tuesday April 14, 2009 @01:19PM (#561847)
Not subjective. It boils down more to feel the fear, but do it anyway. Which is the point of stress innoculation in basic training, police academy, the more advanced stuff of special forces, or even SERE.

Grossman's books describe the physiological effects of stress and combat. Some of the responses are also caused by folks not understanding just what has happened to them, and why is their body acting like this?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survival,_Evasion,_Resistance_a...

High speed driving tends to drive adrenaline levels way up. Police brutality complaints are much higher in the aftermath of high speed pursuits. Yet the tunnel vision and other responses of that kind of driving also affects non-police drivers. We had an incident here in Denver where an ambulance driver t-boned a light rail train. How the heck could someone not see something that's 15 feet tall and 200 feet long? Adrenaline poisoning will do it to you. And I contend that could have been anyone who did that, as well. It takes "innoculation" to learn how your body behaves in these situations, and to do the "right" thing despite what your body wants to do (which in my case is usually puke and soil myself).