#1 is the annoyance cost of having to replace a lightbulb. Almost all of my lights are either recessed in the ceiling or in annoying-to-access fixtures; not having to find a ladder or chair and balance the replacement in one hand is well worth the ~$10-20 LED bulbs cost. Amortized over their expected lifetime it's minuscule and if I move I'm taking the bulbs with me.
So, the price you would use to calculate savings is not your average price / kWh. You should use your max price / kWh.
That's also why if/when you install solar panels on your roof, you recover your investment faster if you don't quite cover your entire electrical needs.
I thought all utilities were on a tiered pricing model. It's actually a technique employed by Arcata, CA to fight pot growing houses [1][2] that use > 600% of the baseline usage.
Also, I have lived places where middle of the day pricing is higher. My utility company just sent me an offer for tiered pricing by time of day. Smart meters help with implementing time of day pricing.
[1] http://www.arcataeye.com/2012/08/measure-i-the-grow-house-el...
[2] http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2012/11/03/pot-tow...
I'm sure it's worthwhile for any heavily-used light even in very cheap areas, but the specific breakeven time will vary quite a bit.
If you live in Iceland, the payback is probably never. If you live in Singapore, you will recoup the cost in months.
I personally use LEDs everwhere except my bathroom during winter, where I use inefficient globe bulbs because it warms the bathroom.
I'm not sure how much of a difference it's likely to make, though. Houses in cold climates usually use more efficient heating systems, so the heat from a light bulb will be pretty costly by comparison. With a 50W savings, the cost for additional heating to make up for that will probably only be equivalent to about 10W of electricity, or less, depending on your setup.
Air conditioning is usually pretty efficient, with efficiencies better than 10 (10W of heat removed for 1W of electricity used). So that 50W savings will still be 55W or less when taking air conditioning into account.
I think you are off by a factor of 3.412. The SEER rating may be 10, but that means you push 10BTUs per Watt Hour, or 2.9 WH/WH.
I am also assuming that burning NatGas produces electricity about 40% efficiency delivered, and burning it at home for heat is about 80% efficient.
You probably should care. It only takes 6 hours per day of usage for your 60W incandecent to suck up $13 of electricity in a year. And you'll have had to change it at least once. The LEDs will last for over a decade.
Yes, if you're only renting a house/apartment for a year then you may not recoup your costs (although it will be close). Similarly if the light is on for less than an hour per day. But if you plan on sticking around awhile it makes complete financial sense. You can literally save $200 per bulb over the lifetime of a bulb used heavily.
Also, the prices will continue to fall.
EDIT: mikeash is right that I should have mentioned the dependancy of efficiency savings on your local electricity prices. I used 10 cents per kilowatt hour, which is a bit under the national average of 12 cents (meaning I was being conservative in potential savings).
http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2011/10/27/141766341/the-pric...