News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A hidden world, growing beyond control by rayiner on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @11:04PM (#5605509)
Some of these criticisms are utterly stupid:

> * Some 1,271 government organizations and 1,931 private companies work on programs related to counterterrorism, homeland security and intelligence in about 10,000 locations across the United States.

Without a mention of how much work these people do on terrorism, it's meaningless. Homeland security is a cross-cutting concern. So Excelon in Illinois might have a program in place to harden their nuclear power plants against potential terrorist attack. Should they be counted as part of this "hidden world" "growing beyond control?"

> * An estimated 854,000 people, nearly 1.5 times as many people as live in Washington, D.C., hold top-secret security clearances.

There are a ton of reasons to have top-secret security clearances that have nothing to do with counterterrorism or intelligence gathering. Anyone doing sensitive military research, for example, will often have a top secret clearance.

> * Many security and intelligence agencies do the same work, creating redundancy and waste. For example, 51 federal organizations and military commands, operating in 15 U.S. cities, track the flow of money to and from terrorist networks.

Again, homeland security is a cross-cutting concern.

> * Analysts who make sense of documents and conversations obtained by foreign and domestic spying share their judgment by publishing 50,000 intelligence reports each year - a volume so large that many are routinely ignored.

50,000 intelligence reports in a year is 136 per day, in a country of 300 million people.

Re:A hidden world, growing beyond control by johnvschmitt on Thursday April 25, 2013 @12:12AM (#5605664)
OK, but look at the growth after 9/11. Are all of those simply hardening/defensive mechanisms?

BTW: I firmly believe that the best defense against a possible attack from ~7B+ people is:

A) in cyberspace: to simply build better security rather than counter-attack those that attack us, as there are countless attackers from anyone with internet, often with nothing to lose, so counter attacks are futile.

B) In physical space: deal with attacks as criminals, not state or stateless organizations that require sacrificing civil liberties & core morals. There are not 7B+ people who can physically attack a structure, so standard policing suffices. Giving them more attention than that is playing directly into their goals, & counter-productive.

C) Nobody likes a police state. Jefferson famously said, that all governments creep towards tyranny, so we must remain vigilant towards increased power for our "safety".

Re:A hidden world, growing beyond control by pmorici on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @11:19PM (#5605545)
I wonder how many items a large newspaper publishes in a typical year? Probably a lot; some of them are short and trivial, not everyone reads everything, they focus on topics that are interesting to them. Seems like the same might apply to intelligence reports.

Edit: To answer my own question, it looks like in the past 365 days the New York Times published over 200,000 articles

http://query.nytimes.com/search/sitesearch/#/*/365days/artic...

If you include blog posts as well it is over 400,000 so by comparison 50k doesn't seem outrageous.

Re:A hidden world, growing beyond control by omd on Thursday April 25, 2013 @12:50AM (#5605770)
It seems beyond outrageous to me. 200k news articles is the amount of news that is produced by 7 billion people in 200 countries worldwide. Those 50k reports is what comes out of counter terrorism by one just of those countries. That's not including the usual declassified military or police reports. There is 1 person for every 400 Americans producing and/or reading these reports. That is more than the total amount of law enforcement officers in the entire US. Tracking every email in and out of the US which seemed impossible before, seems rather trivial now.
Re:A hidden world, growing beyond control by rayiner on Thursday April 25, 2013 @01:15AM (#5605825)
> 200k news articles is the amount of news that is produced by 7 billion people in 200 countries worldwide. Those 50k reports is what comes out of counter terrorism by one just of those countries.

Right, but those 50k reports are about the activities happening among those 7 billion people in 200 countries. And many of those 200k news articles published by the NYT have a corresponding intelligence angle that is covered in the report. Remember, NYT only covers major world news, and a lot of intelligence reports are mundane things like "what is the intelligence impact of this new Russian oil pipeline?"

> There is 1 person for every 400 Americans producing and/or reading these reports.

Where do you get that number? That 830,000 number from the article is for people with top secret clearance. That includes everyone from intelligence analysts to military officers to scientists working on sensitive research.

Re:A hidden world, growing beyond control by hga on Friday April 26, 2013 @10:27AM (#5613078)
Unless you're in intelligence an officer's basic clearance is only Secret.

But the point stands. One of the people I've provided personal references for a TS/SCI first did work for the National Reconnaissance Office (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Reconnaissance_Office):

"The National Reconnaissance Office (NRO), located in Chantilly, Virginia, is one of the 16 U.S. intelligence agencies and considered, along with the CIA, NSA, DIA and NGA, to be one of the "big five" U.S. Intelligence agencies. It designs, builds, and operates the spy satellites of the United States government, and coordinates the analysis of aerial surveillance and satellite imagery from several intelligence and military agencies."

3,000 direct employees, plus many contractors like the above mentioned friend. Is the NRO any bigger because of 9/11 et. al.? Probably somewhat, but not all that much I suspect given how much they were doing before it. What he was doing was just supporting their general efforts. (His following jobs? Well, as usual I can tell you what technology they used, but nothing about them, they're more sensitive, so maybe he became part of this growing post-9/11 "hidden world".)

Re:A hidden world, growing beyond control by wisty on Thursday April 25, 2013 @12:36AM (#5605727)
> cross-cutting concern

Does this mean - they are doing stuff they would have been doing anyway; but with 10X the budget, and 1/10th the efficiency? (Yes, the minute a project gets a security clearance it loses efficiency - mostly because oversight and transparency is now heavily restricted).

Re:A hidden world, growing beyond control by bdunbar on Thursday April 25, 2013 @08:01AM (#5606678)
> There are a ton of reasons to have top-secret security clearances that have nothing to do with counterterrorism or intelligence gathering.

Agreed. I held TS clearance in the Marines for a job that was, bottom-line, 'security guard'.

Re:A hidden world, growing beyond control by ams6110 on Thursday April 25, 2013 @09:46AM (#5607098)
Yeah, one might be tempted to think that if that many people have "top-secret" clearance then stuff probably isn't really very "secret." However having a top-secret clearance doesn't mean you are privy to any and all top-secret classified stuff... you still have to pass the "need to know" hurdle on any specific information.
Re:A hidden world, growing beyond control by hga on Friday April 26, 2013 @10:31AM (#5613100)
However, if they can e.g. allow a black hat access to the seriously classified stuff, they need the high clearance. Be it a Marine "security guard", the janitor, from top to bottom they need to be as trustworthy as we can determine.
Re:A hidden world, growing beyond control by DanBC on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @11:19PM (#5605544)
You're right, some of the criticisms don't make much sense.

But we're going to hear a lot more like this now we know that intelligence was aware of the alleged boston bomber at least a year ago.

Re:A hidden world, growing beyond control by johnvschmitt on Thursday April 25, 2013 @01:23AM (#5605840)
When I hear that the FBI interviewed the Boston bomber a year ago, I don't immediately think of FBI incompetence. No, rather, I think, "Hey, the bomber had many experiences & changes of mind, & is truly a different person a year hence".

I mean, are personalities & motivations & intentions truly permanent? C'mon, haven't we all changed as life goes on?

It's a fallacy to think you can ever 99.9% predict the future regardless of how much "big data" & "army of experts" you have.

That approach hasn't predicted the stock market within 70% accuracy, so how can we expect it to predict security issues any better?

We need to just realize that we're far more likely to die from causes other than terrorism, & just treat it like other crimes.

Re:A hidden world, growing beyond control by danielweber on Thursday April 25, 2013 @12:39PM (#5608209)
If we drag the FBI over the coals for interviewing this guy and failing to stop him, we are shooting ourselves in the foot.

Either the FBI is going to stop interviewing people, or they are going to start putting lots of innocent people in jail.

Re:A hidden world, growing beyond control by cmstoken on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @11:21PM (#5605551)
But they always say that kind of stuff afterwards. How is this time any different?