Re:Fifth Amendment shields child porn suspect from decryptin...
by serans on Thursday April 25, 2013 @03:25PM
(#5609299)
I guess the problem is there's no such a thing as a person having "a 10% chance of being innocent" Either he is or he is not. He might have certain probability of being declared guilty (which is entirely different), but I don't think there's a way to estimate that.
BTW 99% is a very low accuracy. If we accepted that for aircraft, 13 would crash weekly.
It's not a matter of protecting the rights of guilty people or not, but determining how much to protect them. Every procedural protection has a cost. If a procedural protection might be invoked by a person who has a 10% chance of being innocent, then maybe it's worth the cost. If it's more likely to be invoked by a person who has a 1% chance of being innocent, then maybe it's not. Looking only at media reports gives you a distorted picture of what those probabilities are.
> The trope here is the suggestion that criminals are getting off on technicalities.
I didn't say they were getting off on technicalities. I said they were trying to get off on technicalities.
"Better to let a 100 guilty men go free than 1 innocent man go to jail" makes for good rhetoric, but even such flowery language implies a point at which its better to let 1 innocent man go to jail than let a certain number of guilty men go free.