Re:How to cause moral outrage from the entire Internet in te...
by sokoloff on Monday April 13, 2009 @07:10PM
(#560702)
Let's be clear here. Weev didn't censor Amazon listings. If what Weev claims is true, the most you can say is that he helped trick Amazon into choosing, via automated means, to censor those titles.
But ultimately, it was Amazon who took the action to remove the listings.
(Unnecessary disclaimer: I'm a huge fan of Amazon, and hardly a week goes by that I don't buy something or other from them.)
Re:How to cause moral outrage from the entire Internet in te...
by stcredzero on Monday April 13, 2009 @10:19PM
(#560877)
Your logic simply doesn't hold. If some guy repaints highway signs to cause a car crash, then, if anyone dies, he should be up for murder, not the driver. The guilty party is the vandal in both cases, not the driver or the computer operator.
Re:How to cause moral outrage from the entire Internet in te...
by sokoloff on Tuesday April 14, 2009 @08:32AM
(#561348)
I'm going to take one last stab at this, and then let it go:
But he didn't repaint the signs. At worst, he convinced a few other people to call up the DOT and say "That stop sign shouldn't be there, please change it to a 55 MPH speed limit sign." If the DOT then goes and changes the signs without appropriately verifying, then it's on them...
I realize as programmers that we might think Weev's (purported) actions are directly responsible for the de-listing, but they aren't. It's ultimately Amazon's code that did the de-listing.
If his hack involved writing an innocuous demo script and presenting it to Amazon or at a conference, this would be one thing, and society is better off for the freedom to make such discoveries and talk and write about them. Society is certainly better off when it accords freedom of speech. But academic freedom ends where you start to impact other's freedom of speech. (Like effective censorship of Amazon listings.)
All my life, I've had this background occurrence of strangers have coming out of nowhere to try and haze me with some racial epithet. Almost all of these idiots carry this air of striking some sort of blow for truth and beauty, as if they're defending motherhood and the American way through their yelling and insults. To me, Weev and his ilk have the exact same sort of misguided self-righteousness.
I'm sure the one who hazed that young girl into committing suicide on MySpace felt just as clever and justified.
(Many of those Weev targets may have the same self-righteous chip on their shoulder as well, and may be just as bad in their way. It's just not a productive way to expend mental energy.)