News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fifth Amendment shields child porn suspect from decryptin... by smoyer on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @07:47PM (#5604793)
This is one of those issues that leaves you arguing with yourself ... I'm 100% against child pornography (or really the exploitation of anyone), but 100% for rights to privacy, both digitally and in "in real life".

We can only hope that if this suspect is guilty, they find evidence that can be obtained without violating his rights ... and of course if he's innocent, I hope he avoids the stigma being a suspect might bring.

Re:Fifth Amendment shields child porn suspect from decryptin... by aliguori on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @08:32PM (#5604993)
This is not about privacy, it's about self incrimination which is far, far more important.

You can be compelled to testify under oath for many reasons none of which involve doing anything wrong. When you testify under oath, you must answer the questions asked truthfully or face unlimited jail-time for contempt.

The fifth amendment is the only form of protection you have from being called to testify and being grilled about any random topic. It's a balance to the otherwise tremendous power that a court has.

The prosecution must be able to make their case without the defendants assistance. This is a fundamental aspect of our legal system.

Re:Fifth Amendment shields child porn suspect from decryptin... by aspensmonster on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @09:27PM (#5605236)
Unfortunately it seems that discovery and testimony have become increasingly conflated over time. I don't buy the arguments that compelling someone to decrypt something is discovery rather than testimony. The precedent that tips the scale between discovery and testimony hinges on whether the prosecution "knows" that the data is there, which is bogus to begin with precisely because the supposed data is encrypted. They couldn't possibly "know" what is there without compelling the defendant to decrypt. And if there is already "sufficient evidence" to tie a defendant to supposed encrypted data, as has come up in certain cases, than there is no need to compel the defendant to decrypt in the first place. Provide your "sufficient evidence" to the court and let the judge and jury do their jobs.

I think precedent leaned this way precisely because people understood that otherwise, guilty people would definitely walk. And they couldn't have that, even if it meant that the spirit of the 5th amendment was violated.

Re:Fifth Amendment shields child porn suspect from decryptin... by corin_ on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @08:06PM (#5604867)
The problem from the stigma point of view is that, even if our better judgement is saying "stand up for your privacy rights, even if you have nothing to hide", our (or at least my) brain is also saying "if he was innocent he wouldn't have a problem un-encrypting the drive(s) for them".

That's in my head, despite the fact that I am well aware that he could be taking a moral stand, or he could have stuff on those drives which he doesn't want to be seen for reasons completely unrelated to child pornography (maybe photos of his mistress which his wife doesn't know about, maybe profit spreadsheets from his drug-dealing... etc.)

So if he is innocent, I imagine the stigma will be there regardless, assuming people hear about the case at least.

Re:Fifth Amendment shields child porn suspect from decryptin... by rhizome on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @08:20PM (#5604930)
The stigma comes from an attitude that the judicial system's responsibility is to produce convictions, so it appears that defendants who are not convicted are merely certainly-guilty people against whom the prosecution didn't have the tools necessary to convict. Down this path lies lowered standards for due process and evidence and a higher incidence of false positives.
Re:Fifth Amendment shields child porn suspect from decryptin... by anigbrowl on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @08:29PM (#5604982)
the judicial system's responsibility is to produce convictions

No, that's the responsibility of prosecutors. Trial courts are 'finders of fact,' whether or not those facts suit the prosecution.

Re:Fifth Amendment shields child porn suspect from decryptin... by ScottBurson on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @09:24PM (#5605224)
Please read more closely before replying. You missed rhizome's point entirely.
Re:Fifth Amendment shields child porn suspect from decryptin... by anigbrowl on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @10:42PM (#5605460)
I'm not sure that I agree with him about the widespread existence of this attitude, though.
Re:Fifth Amendment shields child porn suspect from decryptin... by rhizome on Thursday April 25, 2013 @02:24PM (#5608956)
In a system that purports to consider suspects innocent until proven guilty, why is there stigma when the suspect is not proven guilty? The suspicion that they are actually guilty supersedes the idea that law enforcement (incl. the prosecutor) is fallible. The stigma derives from an authoritarian mindset in this way.
Re:Fifth Amendment shields child porn suspect from decryptin... by anigbrowl on Thursday April 25, 2013 @04:11PM (#5609555)
Yes, but that's a feature of human psychology. A lot of people are authoritarians, and in a society where free speech is constitutionally protected they enjoy the right to trumpet their opinions about the likely guilt of people being acquitted.
Re:Fifth Amendment shields child porn suspect from decryptin... by rhizome on Thursday April 25, 2013 @04:49PM (#5609767)
So would you agree that "innocent until proven guilty" is basically a lie, since "human psychology" drives society to consider suspects to be always-guilty regardless of the outcome of the accusation? At any rate, the stigma being discussed in this thread derives from this tendency of society, innate to its members or not.
Re:Fifth Amendment shields child porn suspect from decryptin... by anigbrowl on Thursday April 25, 2013 @06:27PM (#5610346)
No, of course not. A court can acquit someone but it can't control how everyone thinks about the process. If a certain percentage of the population are authoritarians who believe the police are always right and defense lawyers are always tricksy shysters, there's not much the court can do about it other than acknowledging the facts that point to an acquittal.

You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make him drink.

Re:Fifth Amendment shields child porn suspect from decryptin... by rhizome on Thursday April 25, 2013 @08:13PM (#5610777)
What do you mean "if" a certain percentage of the population are authoritarians? You just described authoritarianism as (as I interpret you) basic human nature. However, I think it's cultural, so there is more to do than to throw ones hands up in powerlessness, and it has to do with the assumptions people make about the legal system (as I described). Stigma is not an innate attribute like a freckle.

Regardless, we could have shortened this thread considerably if you'd just said "eh, whaddya gonna do?" up front.

Re:Fifth Amendment shields child porn suspect from decryptin... by anigbrowl on Thursday April 25, 2013 @11:55PM (#5611392)
You just described authoritarianism as (as I interpret you) basic human nature.

I said 'a lot of people are authoritarians,' not that it was inherent. It varies from country to country, eg I think Swedes are somewhat less authoritarian than Americans in the aggregate.