News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by pg on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @04:26PM (#5603742)
Impressive move by Spark, who have now put other VCs in the awkward position of explaining why they don't do the same.
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by fredwilson on Thursday April 25, 2013 @05:56AM (#5606415)
Hi Paul

i would prefer to eliminate legal fees entirely by using standard docs and not negotiating them on either side. we have done that many many times and it works great. all you need to do is use a standard template. most law firms have them.

this is what i propose on every seed and series A we do. most entrepreneurs take us up on it. and then we don't even use a lawyer on our side.

however, there are cases, like one you and i have exchanged emails on recently, where a legal issue comes up that is created by the entrepreneur's counsel, that requires a lot of work and sometimes we end up getting stuck with the bill on it.

in situations like that, i like to have the discussion of who should pay the bill up front and on a case by case basis

Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by fghh45sdfhr3 on Thursday April 25, 2013 @11:03AM (#5607585)
Hi Fred and Paul! You don't know me. I just wanted to be able to tell people I said hello to you two once :)
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by msandford on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @04:40PM (#5603822)
The net effect is that they're being more honest about how much they're actually willing to invest, correct? They don't magically have more money and the lawyers have to be paid anyhow. At least it puts the onus on them to keep their negotiations to a minimum.
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by pg on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @04:47PM (#5603858)
There are two groups that benefit, portfolio companies and the VCs' LPs. The former get to keep more of the money that's invested, and the latter are no longer being charged for expenses in addition to the management fees they pay.

In practice, the startups' own legal expenses will probably also be lower. In the bad old days, lawyers on both sides would engage in a leisurely and expensive back and forth, knowing they'd both get paid out of the amount invested. But if the VCs have to pay their lawyers out of their own management fees, they'll instruct them to make the negotiations fast and simple, which will in turn decrease the billable hours on the startup's side as well.

Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by msandford on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @04:56PM (#5603912)
Okay, so I got it half right. They've made the consumer of services and payer for services the same (themselves) and thus they have the proper incentives. This is a bigger win for the startup ecosystem than I had previously thought.
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by not_that_noob on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @06:46PM (#5604480)
Absolutely. Kudos to Spark and I hope the others follow.

And PG, thanks for changing the world. You made the currents swirl in a way that in some small way influence all the ripples like this downstream.

Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by nwenzel on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @06:56PM (#5604515)
The bad old days are still alive and well in insurance and banking. Bankruptcy is even worse.

Eight years in the insurance world has shown me that the two biggest law firm "bad behaviors" are excessive billing and multi-party meetings. Both of which, as noted, VCs will be in a stronger position to refuse to pay.

I call this version of the principal-agent problem the "new boat problem." When a partner wants a new boat, she/he bills more hours.

Even more pumped for YC interview on Sunday after reading the comments.

Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by chipmunc56 on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @04:45PM (#5603854)
this. If I give you $8 and ask you to pay me $2 for expenses, or I give you $6 you don't much care. This would only apply to entrepreneurs who don't know that term sheets are less attorney fees.
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by mentat on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @04:50PM (#5603877)
meta: in the interests of continuing intelligent discussion on HN, please just say what you mean instead of "this". It's an infection that's been spreading for at least a few months here.
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by markokocic on Thursday April 25, 2013 @02:38AM (#5605982)
Sentence containing only word 'this' is automatic down vote when I see it on HN. Even +1 adds more value IMHO.
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by icebraining on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @07:23PM (#5604651)
"This" (noun): same as "I agree."
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by danilocampos on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @07:38PM (#5604734)
That's the problem cited, though. Hacker News, as a community, has developed a comical, pathological aversion to any sort of agreement. Every nit must be picked – otherwise the discussion fails to be "intelligent."
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by jacquesm on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @07:46PM (#5604784)
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by danilocampos on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @09:28PM (#5605240)
Said Twain, "never argue with a fool, onlookers may not be able to tell the difference."
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by SkyMarshal on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @07:40PM (#5604743)
"This" (noun): superfluous unoriginal internet meme language.

Better way: just use your own words, be authentic. Pretend like you're Steve Jobs, and each word you write is your next product.

Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by vidarh on Thursday April 25, 2013 @08:45AM (#5606826)
I love how you suggest that people should stop behaving the way they are in order to "use your own words, be authentic". How is altering their behaviour in order to satisfy someone on a forum being authentic and using their own words?
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by SkyMarshal on Thursday April 25, 2013 @11:01AM (#5607568)
1. On the authenticity scale, meme language is at the very bottom. Anything is an improvement.

2. I didn't tell them what to say, only what not to say. Putting words into their mouth might have been inauthentic, but that's not happening here.

3. Just because people are "behaving the way they are", doesn't make it authentic. In case you haven't realized, we live in a world filled with constant sophisticated attempts at mass behavior modification. We are all victims from time to time, and behooves us to at least be introspective and aware of when we are. (not that meme language is a part of that, it's more an accidental artifact of networked humanity, but point generally applies).

4. Using memes is a rhetorical crutch for lazy writing.

Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by dllthomas on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @11:25PM (#5605563)
I thought it was short for "This [is something I think people should pay attention to]."
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by danilocampos on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @05:09PM (#5603986)
As long as we're being meta...

You responded with 32 words to a 37 word post so that you could quibble about a single word, or 3% of that post. While preaching on the righteous subject of "intelligent discussion," no less. So if we're going to complain about empty calories, I'm pretty sure you're winning that game.

Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by FuzzyDunlop on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @05:21PM (#5604056)
I think you win that, with 54 words nobody needed to read.
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by danilocampos on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @06:52PM (#5604502)
But I love empty calories. Look at my comment history.
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by Retric on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @05:00PM (#5603933)
Technicly this also lowers valuations. Which assuming the percentages stay the same is generally a good thing.
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by harryh on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @06:08PM (#5604321)
This is exactly right, but I prefer the $6 case because it makes it much more obvious what is going on. We should make the truth obvious whenever possible.

Hopefully (as pg points out) the next thing to go is the weird way that employee option pools are handled.

Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by yebyen on Thursday April 25, 2013 @09:14AM (#5606951)
The truth is that lawyers are being paid, whether it comes out of your pocket or mine. It's very generous but as a person who has never received a term sheet at all, one way or another I see it as turning another part of the process more opaque.

What if I never have to pay another lawyer?

Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by nwenzel on Thursday April 25, 2013 @11:38AM (#5607796)
Actually, that's not entirely true. If lawyers bill inappropriate charges, you don't have to pay those charges. Inappropriate charges include excessive hours, administrative tasks, overhead, or other charges you disallow based on your agreement (commonly called Billing Guidelines). Based on data I've worked with (insurance companies, financial services company, real estate firms) those inappropriate charges are anywhere from 5-15% of the total. Usually 5-10%.

The advantage of having the VC pay the legal bills is that they are a bigger fish and can more easily put in place and enforce the legal billing guidelines. Also, as a much more likely repeat customer, the VC will likely get better bills to begin with.

Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by yebyen on Thursday April 25, 2013 @11:50AM (#5607892)
Interesting... sounds like a problem that might apply too outside of the legal profession.
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by downandout on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @06:42PM (#5604456)
Not that a traditional VC will ever hand me a term sheet (I wouldn't approach one), but if one did and it specified that I had to pay their legal expenses, I would reject it on principle. It's rather underhanded, and I would immediately begin scouring the paperwork to see what other sleazy tactics they were employing.
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by jacquesm on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @07:45PM (#5604777)
If you were in a position to read / sign such a terms sheet then you may want to ask why it specifies that before you reject it out of hand.

And you should scour all the paperwork regardless of whether or not that clause was present, even better, have a lawyer that you pay (preferably a competent one) help with the scouring.

Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by mjn on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @10:43PM (#5605461)
It would be particularly odd to reject it over solely that, because it's just a fixed-dollar difference. One easy way to overcome a finite difference in one part of a term sheet is to offer more dollars in another part.

All Spark is doing here is offering to cover the first $25k of legal expenses. The startup is still liable for anything above that. That's an offer worth at most $25k in additional implied investment, relative to the case where they asked the startup to cover all legal fees. Actuarially, probably somewhat lower than $25k. So maybe you should value the offer at $15k. Not nothing, but not worth overriding everything else.

Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by downandout on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @08:09PM (#5604882)
Of course anyone would use a lawyer in such a situation. I'm just saying that it is indicative of a hair-splitting, underhanded mentality that would raise immediate red flags about doing business with them in the first place.
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by jacquesm on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @08:19PM (#5604925)
> indicative of a hair-splitting, underhanded mentality

I believe you may be wrong about that. But it appears you've now found a good match in Spark! On the down side, it may then be the only game in town for you, there are good reasons for the 'company pays fees' rule, see elsewhere in this thread for one possible reason.

Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by downandout on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @09:27PM (#5605235)
As previously stated, I have never and would never approach a traditional VC in the first place for a host of reasons, this being one of them. There is no VC game in town for me, and I am perfectly content with that.
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by tptacek on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @08:57PM (#5605103)
Having done this, and, um, other things: legal fees for an unremarkable deal go to high five figures easy; sometimes they go much, much higher.
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by tptacek on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @08:01PM (#5604847)
You'd be rejecting most deals, then, because what Spark is doing is unusual.
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by wpietri on Thursday April 25, 2013 @09:01AM (#5606894)
It's not underhanded if everybody knows its coming.

I was shocked the first time I saw this, but I called around and discovered that it's one of the things VCs do because they can. Since our VC was no worse than anybody else, I put it in the "fine, whatever, fuck you, but fine" category of things. It didn't end up even being in my top 10 things I'd change about traditional venture capital operations.

If you object to every fucked up thing about the system you're in, it's very hard to get the power to reform the system. I'm perfectly happy to beat my head against a wall, but I try to pick the walls that are ready to break. As Confucius said: "The Historiographer Yu was truly of straight character. When the government was just, he was like an arrow. When the government was unjust, he was like an arrow. Chu Po Yu is definitely a Superior Man. When the government is just, he will have a position in it. When the government is unjust he can roll up his principles and keep them in his breast."

So bravo for Spark for being the leader on this. It's really nice to what entrepreneurs turned investors are doing. I'm glad Nabeel didn't turn down that VC money on principle back in the day, or he might not now be in the position to try to fix this.

Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by greghinch on Thursday April 25, 2013 @12:01AM (#5605645)
Considering how much time and work (3 months of back and forth on DD is not uncommon) it takes you to get to the point of getting a term sheet, I doubt it. Doubled by the fact that, until this posting, every VC I've heard of asks you to pay legal fees.

Now some add other fees on as well. This is considered less scrupulous and should be rejected. But to make things easy, ask about fees up front, not when you are getting a term sheet.

Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by jacquesm on Thursday April 25, 2013 @02:54AM (#5606018)
It is very well possible to have a terms sheet ahead of the DD.
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by ganeumann on Thursday April 25, 2013 @09:38AM (#5607052)
As an angel investor, always investing through a syndicate, it's just far easier to have the company pay the bill. But keep in mind that they're paying with the money that the investors give them, and that this is the EXPLICIT deal.

When I lead a syndicate deal, I am the person that works with the investors' lawyer to get the deal done. But I'm never the majority of the round (or even the largest single investor.) But being the person who retained the lawyer for the investor group, I am on the hook for the bill.

I'm happy doing the work of getting the deal papered, but I wouldn't be happy if I had to pay the whole legal bill when I'm only putting in 10-20% of the round's money.

There are two ways to share the expense:

1) I pay the lawyer then go around to the other investors asking them to pay me their piece. Anyone who has ever been saddled with being the payor of the bill for a large group of people at a bar or restaurant knows how this turns out. Some people forget, some people argue that they should pay less, and it's a huge logistical hassle creating nothing but bad feelings. I suppose I could get each investor to sign something saying they would pay me their share, but that's just more legal expense.

2) We up-front tell the company that they are paying the investors' legal bill (last time I did this, the bill was $6k, the cap was $10k: I don't do fancy deals.) The company factors this into their calculation of whether the investment structure is one they want to accept or not.

Number 2 is nothing more than a structural convenience. But without it I wouldn't take on the burden of leading deals: it would be more trouble than it's worth (note that, as lead, I get the exact same economic terms as the rest of the group, so I'm essentially doing free work when I'm leading and the other investors get the benefit.)

So I'm sticking with having the company pay the legal bill. If we're negotiating a deal and this (or any other term) seems unfair, we need to sit down and talk about it. Once my money is in your bank account and a couple of your stock certificates are under my mattress we're on the same team. We both have a huge incentive to make sure neither of us feels like we've been taken advantage of.

Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by larrys on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @04:44PM (#5603844)
Before the other VC's are in that awkward position this would have to reach some kind of critical mass or tipping point.

Not only that but different sellers, vendors, sides of business transactions, typically offer different terms, features, benefits.

The standard procedure when someone brings up something someone else is willing to do, is to bring up your strong points and why that particular feature shouldn't matter that much as a differentiator. And the truth is how much does this really matter vs. the benefits of the particular VC firm?

Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by pg on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @04:55PM (#5603908)
That would be true if this were morally neutral. But when you're fixing an abuse that's justified by all participants as being standard practice, the right metaphor is not critical mass but a crack in dam.
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by nabeel on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @05:13PM (#5604009)
Well put pg. It isn't that the money was that material, it just felt wrong and petty that it was being done in the first place so we wanted to fix it. Just feels silly we didn't do it a lot sooner.
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by jacquesm on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @08:26PM (#5604962)
Is your fund sales tax exempt? (In other words are you able to deduct sales tax from your earnings before taxes?)

If so you may just end up making the tax man happy and reducing the amount you can invest by whatever sales tax applies in your location. Depending on your process costs and deal-flow this could add up over time.

Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by tptacek on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @09:04PM (#5605137)
Sales tax?
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by jacquesm on Thursday April 25, 2013 @02:56AM (#5606023)
In the EU sales tax (VAT, whatever) is added to every business-to-business transaction and later refunded. If your fund is classed as financial services sector then you may be sales tax exempt. This has certain tax advantages but really doesn't help when you start to receive substantial bills (such as legal fees on a transaction of this magnitude) with sales tax added to them because you can't deduct the sales tax on your own filings.
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by tptacek on Thursday April 25, 2013 @08:36AM (#5606796)
Yeah, not here.
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by darkarmani on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @10:51PM (#5605479)
Maybe for catering all of the multiparty meetings?
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by larrys on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @05:18PM (#5604036)
"But when you're fixing an abuse that's justified by all participants as being standard practice"

I don't feel (given what I know about this) that it's an "abuse" or though I can absolutely see what it is viewed this way. And of course the people who are charging it are going to justify it by saying "it's standard practice" because that is the easiest way to get beyond the objection and smooth things out.

People have certain ideas of what they find right and just and don't think rationally about what it really means relative to the entire transaction.

For example you could go to a restaurant where the steak dinner costs $30 but feel it is an abuse because they want $1.50 for a glass of tap water. Or they want to charge you to use the restroom. But if you go to an equivalent restaurant which charges $35 and gives you free tap water and bathroom you wouldn't think twice (merely focusing on whether you think you got value for the $35 meal).

The reason people have to rely on arguments of "standard practice" is because they are quick and easy and get by objections much easier then a lengthy discussion. It's a time saver.

Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by tibbon on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @04:59PM (#5603925)
Is there any compelling reason (aside from money...) that others won't make the move as well?
Re:Spark Capital will now pay their own legal bills by johnrob on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @05:19PM (#5604044)
Related question: will not making this move affect a firm's ability to get good deals? I don't know the answer but it's what the firms should ask themselves.