This guy is a jerk, and he's making society slightly less good. As a society, we should try and avoid the tragedy of the commons, or else we won't have a society for much longer. Someone needs to remind this guy, in an official capacity, that his actions are not appreciated or tolerated.
Amazon shouldn't just blindly accept data and trust it is legitimate.
Same with creating false accounts.
You can't really compare it with breaking and entering a house.
At the end of the day, IMHO this shouldn't be illegal, and no action should be taken. Amazon was extremely silly to accept user flagging from a GET request in an iframe.
How is what your're saying different from, "I didn't send those DDOS packets, the lusers executing my trojan program did!"
How about: "IMHO, that shouldn't be illegal. Mrs. Smith was extremely silly to believe that a consumer door lock and sticking her life savings under her mattress was a good way to secure money."
The correct response IMHO is for Amazon to realize they were stupid, and fix it. If you sue etc you put out the signal that being stupid is fine - you'll be able to sue someone if they take advantage of your stupidity.
But then we live in an age where if someone doesn't tell you explicitly that your coffee is hot, and you spill it, you can sue them...
Also, you can argue that not suing is sending out the wrong message -- that manipulating the flagging mechanism is cool, so long as you're a cool, clever hacker.
If I was running a business, and my employee left a storage shed unlocked, I shouldn't prosecute the thieves because I did something "stupid?" Uh, no. Most people would suggest that you make sure locking the shed is on the checklist and you prosecute.
Someone else being stupid doesn't give you a "Get away with being an asshat" card.
It's like those people who buy those terrible cheap car alarms that go off at anything at all and then don't stop for an hour. Their car is sitting there, ruining everyone's quality of life with its incessant blaring. Can they just excuse themselves by saying "well it's not me, it's the car alarm"? Of course not. If you own something, and that something is capable of harm, it's your responsibility to ensure its integrity. Blithe ignorance is no excuse at all.
The door lock/money under the mattress analogy doesn't hold up. Mrs Smith did not invite millions of visitors from around the world into her house to walk around her bedroom, relying solely on the mattress to hide her treasure, and if she had no-one would have much sympathy when one of them eventually looked there. Amazon did invite such behaviour and should have taken appropriate safeguards. This is no-one's fault but their own.
If Mrs. Smith was running a bric-a-brac store and didn't know how to secure her display cases, then it's alright to shoplift from her?
If Mrs. Smith was holding a big party at her house, then it's alright for a party goer to steal her life savings?
If I hand a firearm disguised as a jelly donut to a random bystander, then they shoot someone with it, it's their fault and not mine?
Amazon messed up. It doesn't justify Weev's action. He could've just told them. Deception and malicious intent are markings of crime or antisocial behavior. That's just common sense!
The fact is, nothing was stolen and no-one died. You're all about "intent" so intend this: this whole story is one guy exploiting Amazon's flawed security to annoy gay people.
I do not even like Weev. This is nothing but principle, namely - should the government be papering, with the full force of the law, over the cracks in Amazon's security?
I say, "no". You say "yes". We are each convinced of our righteousness. Let's leave it there.
Someone absconding with that bag is stealing. Period. They didn't pay for that bag, why are they leaving the store with it? The thief is wrong. Nothing grey about that.
The problem here is that Weev's intent was to deceive and have a particular group's books effectively censored. This fits in with Amazon's Terms of Use? I don't think so. There is no grey area. If Weev wanted to improve the world with his hacking, there are tons of ways he could've done this without hurting anyone (reduced income), deceiving anyone, or running afoul of the TOS.
Prediction: if you go any further, your analogy generator is just going to illuminate how far you have to grasp for straws. (And I'll also note that I have been careful to construct relevant analogies, usually 2 or 3 at a time, picking the best fit. Also, your feedback in the discussion has resulted in iteratively more damning analogies.)
Let's see it!
Giving false feedback?"
Well then, unless your actual name is "tjic" then we are both criminals right off the bat. And since when is the government in the business of checking whether feedback is "false" or not? That's the company's job. It's not illegal to lie unless you are under oath, and nobody was.
"Restraint of trade?"
I don't see how Amazon's trade has been restrained in any way, shape or form. Unless you consider criticism or bad reputation to be restraint of trade, in which case any criticism is fair game. Very dangerous ground.
"but I have no problem at all with the government enforcing laws against using aliases to log into a system and inject bad data in order to create a public relations firestorm?"
Who says it's bad data? What's wrong with aliases? You're trying to legislate against intent.
And your example of how Joe Schmoe should be protected even though he's slagging off Microsoft - MS will say that's bad data bringing a PR firestorm. It just doesn't work.
"I'd be somewhat pissed if someone used my flawed front door lock (pickable by anyone with a set of picks, 60 seconds to spare, and decent picking skills) against me."
Dear god, not this argument again. Look, physical security is NOT the same as network security. It is impossible to totally guarantee physical security. It is possible, even easy, to create perfect network security. The two are totally at odds. Creating a few fake accounts and submitting some votes (which Amazon encourages) is not even remotely similar to breaking into your house and placing signs advertising your partiality to child molestation.
You are giving Amazon a free pass for their lax security practises, and placing all the blame on some random guy who had the balls to admit he did it. And if it was illegal, the only thing that would change is that he wouldn't have admitted it. You can't have laws like that. You may as well try to make a law that everyone has to be nice.
Under US law, there is no such thing as a sole "actual" name. Any name that you use for non-fraudulent purposes is a legitimate name.
TJIC is my initials: Travis James Ignatius Corcoran.
I have been using it as a legitimate name for 15 years. My mom addresses emails and letters to me using that name.
So, no, I'm not a criminal.
...but if someone signed up for an account at Amazon using 500 different names, and one of them was "TJIC", and the intent was to inject bad data ... yes, that person would be a criminal.
"but if someone signed up for an account at Amazon using 500 different names, and one of them was "TJIC", and the intent was to inject bad data ... yes, that person would be a criminal."
No way. Guaranteeing the integrity of Amazon's Customer Review data is not the job of the state. Guaranteeing the legitimacy of the name(s) used to sign up for accounts is not the job of the state. Assessing the state of mind of someone filling in Amazon's complaints form is not the job of the state.
I am kind of amazed you think the government or the law should be even tangentially involved in any of this.
According to many theories, much of the point of the state is to lower transaction costs.
That's why states get involved in things like creating default rental agreements, setting up standards of weight and measure, inspecting pumps at gas stations, stamping out ponzi schemes, running courts to enforce slander laws (even when the target is a corporation), etc.
I'm a pretty extreme libertarian. I'd like 99% of the government to go away. Maybe more.
...but I'm going to assume that we're holding this debate in the real world, not in a science-fictional Heinlein-esque anarcho-capitalist moon colony. ...and if that's the case, then 99.9% of people think the job of the state DOES include stopping people from intentionally gumming up third party transactions.
Sometimes that's a sign that your point of view is out of whack. (And being able to realize this is a mark of true learning. And yeah, it is painful sometimes.)
What happened here is more like Whole Foods setting out free samples. If someone concocted a scheme to walk out the front door with all of the free samples, I would not be at all surprised if the perpetrator were taken off to jail. "But Whole Foods encourages you to take them!" yeah, right. Something smacks of rationalization here.
Same goes for you, of course ; )
Unfortunately, regardless of who is ethically right or wrong, my view will retain the upper hand, for the simple fact that the network is global, and whatever laws you pass in any country will not, nor ever, apply to all. For this simple reason you must continue to consider security the sole responsible of the proprietor, and assume the complete legal immunity of the customer/attacker (same thing).
"If someone concocted a scheme to walk out the front door with all of the free samples"
I do not particularly care for the idea of the judiciary being involved in rationing out Whole Foods' free samples. I do see your point - theft is theft, after all - but do you really want to make an obvious prank illegal? Outright shoplifting is one thing. Pranks are another, and they were free samples. You're so enthusiastic to consider intent in your other examples, why forget all about it in this one?
It's not the intent as a prank that's the problem. It's the intent to have the particular effect that he did. I'm sure Amazon's Terms of Use would preclude what he did.
Registering multiple false user names?
Giving false feedback?
Restraint of trade?
I'm not a fan of government prosecuting someone for registering on Facebook with the user name "Joe Schmoe" in order to blog anonymously about their crappy job at Microsoft.
...but I have no problem at all with the government enforcing laws against using aliases to log into a system and inject bad data in order to create a public relations firestorm?
> He merely used Amazon's flawed system against them
I'd be somewhat pissed if someone used my flawed front door lock (pickable by anyone with a set of picks, 60 seconds to spare, and decent picking skills) against me.
"Oh, all I did was hang a sign in the window saying 'A child molester lives here' - what LOLZ!"
Yeah, OK, great, that's a wonderful "hack".