Says Cardinal Ximenez. Pinning the very real problems facing colleges and universities on one cause, top-heavy administration, and then insisting that it can be remedied somehow through technology is simplistic.
The reason I think it is most critical is two-fold. First, extra administration just pulls money away from the actual teaching in salaries. But worse, the costs grow exponentially, as administrators ensure people know the "value they bring" or grow their "fiefdoms". The actions wind up creating additional costs and drag throughout the organization.
Universities have seen a near doubling of non-teaching staff[1][2]. These people do not bring much value to students, instead, they focus on the university. But it's the students that pay their salaries.
Now, a bigger question is how to fix it. The reading I've done on it lays much of the blame on the easy availability of student loans: they've allowed universities to jack up tuition prices well beyond the consumer index. Universities kept the teaching ratio about the same[1], so students get roughly the same education, while employing many other professionals and administrators with the extra money they could pull out of the system. Because they can continue raising tuition, they have a way to keep their staff through spending cuts from their funding sources.
To fix the administration problem, you have to fix the student loan problem. Unfortunately, it's a catch 22.
1. http://www.washingtonmonthly.com/magazine/septemberoctober_2...
2. http://www.economist.com/news/united-states/21567373-america...
They are expanding the faculty, too. But here is the problem: there isn't an infinite supply of capable students; the squabble that is going to happen for the few capable students in the mediocre horde isn't going to be fun. I predict that the model isn't going to be successful, but I cannot see what is going to take its place.
But you are right, it is going to get ugly as more students question the value of an education versus not or look to other alternatives. The higher ed balloon is stretch pretty thin right now and easy student loans are the only thing left inflating it, IMO.
It's going to pop, and I wouldn't want to be employed in higher ed when it does.
http://www.sacbee.com/statepay/
Add up the loans and loan interest to build out sports facilities, hundreds of "athletic directors", bunch of underlings they direct on a daily basis, staff and maintenance hired to run the sports facilities, sports scholarships handed out to gifted students, multiply by number of universities and it starts to add up.
The problems is that there are many more that sink dollars into programs irresponsibly because they either irrationally believe they will get a profitable program or feel like they have to maintain some level of "sporting commitment" for its own sake.
The data is ugly.[1]
1. http://www.usatoday.com/sports/college/story/2012-05-14/ncaa...
Most of the time they're hidden on university's balance sheet apart from athletic program budget, since in theory a brand new stadium, training facility, basketball court or swimming pool is used by staff, faculty and students outside of athletic departments.
If the economic incentive was there, a host of private operators would bid to operate an athletic team and facility on a for-profit basis with school getting a cut of the action, sort of what you see with cafeteria, swag stores and other commercial outlets.
However, the other thing it doesn't show, which is also probably hard to quantify, is how much donor money comes in to the main fund because of continued interest in sporting (I believe my link shows contributions directly to the sporting program). Another factor is the marketing impact to prospective students who choose their school off if their teams.
I'm sure the politics and internal value judgements are complicated, but, as much as I enjoy my alma matter beating up on our rivals, I would enjoy my tax burden and my kids' tuition burden (which comes out of my pocket) to be less. More transparency on the subject would be nice.
But my understanding, in my state, and I have skin in the game, is that tuition is rising as state subsidies are declining, pretty much 1:1. Whereas previously residents would get a discount compared to out of state students, pretty soon there will be no discount.
Said another way, all of my state's universities will be 100% tuition supported within a few years.
1. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-11-14/bureaucrats-paid-25...