News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Counsyl is Pioneering A New Bioinformatics Wave by drakaal on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @10:11PM (#5599250)
I like things like this for diagnosis. The problem is in how insurance, employers, parents, and prospective mates will view it. GATTACA jumps to mind.

Just because you can mine the email on Gmail to find everyone who secretly likes Justin Bieber and market to them doesn't mean you should. My genetics are much the same. Until I can mine them in the privacy of my own home with my own equipment and control what data is shared I won't do it.

I don't know if HIPAA governs the privacy of Counsyl, but even at that level of medical privacy I'm not sure I would want it. being disqualified from insurance, or military or being an astronaut because I got a swab of my cheek is not worth it.

[edit] fixed Gattaca spelling as mentioned by others.

Re:Counsyl is Pioneering A New Bioinformatics Wave by _ihaque on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @10:16PM (#5599275)
Insurers have been barred by law from discriminating based on genetic information since 2008: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_Information_Nondiscrimi....

Counsyl definitely falls under the scope of HIPAA; we do tests at the request of physicians, so we're like any other lab as far as privacy is concerned. Your employer, parents, or prospective mate would only know about the results if you decide to tell them.

It's also important to note exactly what Counsyl is testing: we're look at severe single-gene disorders, things that in most cases cause severe disability or early death. Importantly, if you only have one defective copy of a gene for which we test, you won't show symptoms of the disease. This is not the kind of thing that should affect your employer or insurer. And, if you're a carrier, it's probably something you should discuss with your prospective mate: if he or she is also a carrier for the same disease, there's a 1/4 chance of your child having that severe condition.

*edit to add the last paragraph

Re:Counsyl is Pioneering A New Bioinformatics Wave by drakaal on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @10:27PM (#5599333)
Legally if you fail to disclose that you knew you are a carrier for a severe disease to a prospective spouse prior to marriage it could be grounds for annulment, or a fault divorce. Sorry I don't have the case law at the moment, but I am aware that there was such a case involving Huntington's disease.
Re:Counsyl is Pioneering A New Bioinformatics Wave by cdjk on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @01:24AM (#5599995)
Huntington's disease is autosomal dominant, so essentially you're going to get it or not. I don't believe counsyl tests for Huntington's, and probably only tests for recessive traits where you can be a carrier like cystic fibrosis.

I can kind of understand that logic with Huntington's but I'd be surprised if it applied to recessive traits as well.

Re:Counsyl is Pioneering A New Bioinformatics Wave by drakaal on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @10:23PM (#5599307)
GINA is Only for predisposition. Anything that is diagnosed through genetics is fair game. If you use genes to detect that I have something like Fabry Disease which you either have or you do not based on the genes you can be asymptomatic and still have the disease and you will develop it eventually.
Re:Counsyl is Pioneering A New Bioinformatics Wave by drakaal on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @10:31PM (#5599347)
Your statement about privacy is already suspect since your opening comment talks about sharing that data. The two are mutually exclusive. As soon as your system is sharing, rather than me sharing I have no privacy.
Re:Counsyl is Pioneering A New Bioinformatics Wave by pyre on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @11:15PM (#5599516)
It depends on the level of 'sharing.' If it's just statistics (e.g. 10% of people that use our service have discovered X disease), then I don't know how much of your privacy is pierced.
Re:Counsyl is Pioneering A New Bioinformatics Wave by drakaal on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @12:45AM (#5599866)
I do data mining. Ready here we go.

10% of people who used service discovered they have BrandonWirtz's Disease.

Requirements: Male. Primarily Caucasion as primarily limited to Arian Descent. Symptoms onset at 55. Not symptomatic for those with BMI under 22.

With this information I can take the 100% and cut the list to 50% that are male. 50% that are caucasion. (25%) Would have already know if they were over 55 so we cut another 25% Strip last names for ones that would not be of the right heritage. Suddenly the eligible candidates are only 12% of the total. I know that 80% of those are the people on that list.

That's how mining works.

You can't share data anonymously becuase each facet of data allows me more information to piece things together.

Sharing has to be opt in. But if it is opt in then it is no longer statiscitally relevant. Because just as an example. People are going to be less apt to share data if they have a disease associated with a stigma. Which will skew the results.

[Brandon Wirtz's Disease is an imaginary disease used for demonstration only. I don't have any genes shared with other humans as I am from another planet.]

Re:Counsyl is Pioneering A New Bioinformatics Wave by lightcatcher on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @01:22AM (#5599992)
I'm currently taking a class in data privacy, which is about assessing privacy risks using a mathematically rigorous formalization (differential privacy, see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Differential_privacy ) and developing algorithms to allow for minimal risk release of private databases and avoid attacks like yours above. Your post makes it seem like you might enjoy reading more about the field; you should check out this survey of the field: http://www.cs.ucdavis.edu/~franklin/ecs289/2010/dwork_2008.p...
Re:Counsyl is Pioneering A New Bioinformatics Wave by drakaal on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @03:15AM (#5600277)
Those formula's assume the creator knows all the variables. I have data on things like Probablity a First name is of which race. When names started to appear for determining maximum Age. Search data for identifying people who were worried they had a disease.

Often a single piece of data will cause the intersection of two traits to be 80% accurate. You can't mathmatically predict these things because you don't know how many factors I have.

There are zip codes where only 1 in 100 people are of a given race. There are diseases that only 1 in 100k people have done a search for and only 1 in 500k people have. These kinds of things you can't formulaize.

Re:Counsyl is Pioneering A New Bioinformatics Wave by lightcatcher on Thursday April 25, 2013 @04:14AM (#5606170)
This is not true at all. Differential privacy works to counteract EXACTLY these types of attacks. There are some very basic proofs that the privacy guarantees of a differential private release mechanism is not at all weakened by external data, such as what you've listed. Differential privacy attempts to minimize the risk of being a row in a database given that the attacker knows the values of every other row (and has whatever external data he wants).
Re:Counsyl is Pioneering A New Bioinformatics Wave by pyre on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @08:51PM (#5605064)
Maybe I'm missing something. How does "10% of our customers have X disease" allow you to get down to a specific person?

  | With this information I can take the 100% and cut the list
  | to 50% that are male. 50% that are caucasion. (25%) Would
  | have already know if they were over 55 so we cut another
  | 25% Strip last names for ones that would not be of the right
  | heritage. Suddenly the eligible candidates are only 12% of
  | the total.

  | I know that 80% of those are the people on that
  | list.
What list? Are you somehow taking a list of names from outside and correlating them based just on 'X%'?
Re:Counsyl is Pioneering A New Bioinformatics Wave by drakaal on Thursday April 25, 2013 @12:54PM (#5608309)
Things like cookie inspection allow a data miner to get a list of known customers of a company. I can tell you every RackSpace Customer, Every Amazon Shopper, Every FaceBook User.

If you have seen those ads on FB that are for something you just searched on Amazon, or that want to sell you hosting for a place you already have hosting with you know what I mean.

If you have enough data about the factors that are common of people with a disease, and then compare that with percentage of people known to have that disease from a set.

If 10% of Company's American clients have Disease X, and Disease X requires you live in a cold climate to be diagnosed ( Raynaud's for example ) then you can exclude the people who live in a warm climate.

Now if you want to target people with Raynauds and you know 80% of the clients live in California,Texas, And Nevada. You know that 50% of the remaining clients have Raynaud's.

This is of course a contrived example, and uses much less data than would be used by a Data Miner.

For the people saying "no there are formula's we can prevent this from happening" yeah you know who made those formula's? The People who make money selling data. And thos formulas are to keep you from thinking it is dangerous.

Re:Counsyl is Pioneering A New Bioinformatics Wave by _ihaque on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @11:51PM (#5599669)
Yes, you have the right idea. Check out our (open-access) paper from last fall: http://www.nature.com/gim/journal/v15/n3/full/gim2012114a.ht...
Re:Counsyl is Pioneering A New Bioinformatics Wave by Pwnguinz on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @10:14PM (#5599266)
I think you meant GATTACA, the movie? To anyone who hasn't seen it, fantastic movie. Highly recommended.

Re: your other points. I think your concerns are well placed, however this isn't something that's specific to Counsyl; 23andme presumably also carries the same risks. At any rate, I do believe they hold your genetic information to the same standards as required in HIPAA.

Re:Counsyl is Pioneering A New Bioinformatics Wave by bayesianhorse on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @11:38PM (#5599611)
There is growing evidence that genetic testing to the extend it is used in GATTACA is impossible. For example you can't predict a baby's future height. Sure, you can tell a normal distribution from genetics which is narrower than the distribution of the general population, but it's not as predictive as people might assume.

Genetic data has proven to yield a lot less information than was expected. That might change in the future, but I don't believe health insurance companies could make a business case for genetic discrimination even if they were allowed too.

Re:Counsyl is Pioneering A New Bioinformatics Wave by Pwnguinz on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @02:13AM (#5600140)
I agree with you completely. I was merely pointing out that it was a great sci-fi movie worth watching. Not as some sort of foreshadowing of future societal outcome. Plus, what's portrayed in the movie (i.e. discrimination based on genetics) is disallowed by law, at least in California.