Re:Facebook tries Google's WebP image format; users squawk
by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @02:50AM
(#5593654)
So it looks like it is effective in web use cases, like lossy photos (especially with alpha), logos, icons etc., but not for non-web cases like large, lossless photos that need to be compressed quickly. Seems like a good engineering tradeoff to me.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Facebook tries Google's WebP image format; users squawk
by acdha on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @10:52AM
(#5595443)
First, declaring everything WebP is bad at as "non web" assumes that everyone uses the web only for things they don't care about, which isn't remotely true as the original article shows. People save what they can see - and normal people don't want to switch tools for each situation.
Second, it's still not the case that WebP offers a significant advantage over JPEG-2000 or JPEG-XR, both of which are standardized, better supported, more flexible, and have much better designed file formats.