News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who Cares If It's Been Tried Before? by jacquesm on Monday April 22, 2013 @03:13PM (#5591204)
The only important factor in 'it's been tried before' is the 'before' bit, the timing. If the timing was off and that's why the venture failed then re-doing it makes sense. If there was some other factor why a venture failed and it wasn't timing then it does not even count. But 'tried before and failed' will stick for everything where timing wasn't a factor.

During the .com heydays lots of concepts were floated and failed that are successful today. One interesting one is chatroulette, videochat with random partners. Youtube is another, instagram a third. All of those had been tried before but without success because the market just wasn't ready for it. So if you can identify the cause of the mis-fire and it is timing then by all means do a re-run.

Re:Who Cares If It's Been Tried Before? by ChuckMcM on Monday April 22, 2013 @07:36PM (#5592391)
I see this all the time, and the challenge is that 'ideas' never occur in a vacuum. Even when the people who have the idea don't consider any of the things going on around them, the success of those ideas are controlled by forces outside and sometime unrecognized.

One of the classics for me was the 'video phone' which was (and remains) a stupid idea. The idea that you would have a device, that only allowed you to communicate with the same family of devices, and provided by a single provider. Is stupid. The idea that you could interact with someone over a network in real time via a combined video and audio stream is a good one.

When Bell Labs proposed the video phone you could use a $1,500 hard wired terminal to send a 262 x 184 grainy black and white video stream to another person who used the same kind of dedicated $1,500 terminal. Not a lot of value to the end user there.

When you could use a $25 web camera and a bit of software to create a video and audio connection between your $1,500 computer and someone elses computer with a webcam, the computer and networking costs were already 'sunk' in the sense they already had justified their value, so video conferencing only needed to meet the marginal value of being able to see who you were talking too.

The difference between 'success' and 'failure' here was the environment in which the idea was presented, and the amount of value the idea brought relative to the cost of doing it. In the context of today's $29.99 cable internet video conferencing is a great idea, with $2,000/month 1.544Mbit T-1 lines it was a stupid idea.

Re:Who Cares If It's Been Tried Before? by mitchell360 on Monday April 22, 2013 @07:58PM (#5592468)
I totally agree with this notion about "timing." MICHAEL RAYNOR has some good research in The Strategy Paradox. One of his central points is that all of the behaviors that create "knock it out of the park" success are the same behaviors that create bankruptcies. He uses the classic example re: Apple, but also provides many others.

http://cdn.dupress.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/US_deloitt...

Re:Who Cares If It's Been Tried Before? by chacham15 on Monday April 22, 2013 @05:16PM (#5591814)
>The only important factor

I disagree with that part of your statement. Take for example, Dropbox. The main difference between Dropbox and previous attempts was not timing, but rather execution.

Re:Who Cares If It's Been Tried Before? by ThomPete on Monday April 22, 2013 @05:54PM (#5591987)
Using a term like execution to describe why someone is successful is tautological and IMO meaningless.

What's more important is to figure out what the actual execution consisted of.

For instance it's speculated that one of the reasons why Dropbox got a lot of cover was that they where Mac based rather than Windows based.

Since a lot of tech-journalists have Macs it was easier for them to try out and write about it:

"My earlier version of this post was about how Syncplicity and Dropbox competed for mindshare back in 2008 when both companies launched. My initial Quora post was about some of the reasons why, around our respective launches, Dropbox was able to get more attention. 3 years ago, the press and early tech adopters were starting to fall in love with Mac products. The average consumer didn't have a Mac, but they were hot amongst influencers. Having a Windows-only product dramatically limited the attention Syncplicity received from the press. Today, I can't imagine launching a desktop app without Mac support. When we started developing Syncplicity, it wasn't obvious that Mac support was critical for press attention. Today both companies have Mac clients."

http://www.quora.com/Dropbox/Why-is-Dropbox-more-popular-tha...

Re:Who Cares If It's Been Tried Before? by hobs on Monday April 22, 2013 @09:27PM (#5592791)
It is meaningless, but I think saying "it was that one thing" is also probably being too specific, and there is a requirement for a happy medium.

If the answer was obvious (in hindsight even) usually it is imo, an oversimplification of success.

Many times success isnt doing one thing right, its doing the right things right enough, and the wrong things not often enough to piss everyone off.

Re:Who Cares If It's Been Tried Before? by chacham15 on Monday April 22, 2013 @07:02PM (#5592262)
I understand what you are saying, but as the saying goes: "a little inaccuracy saves a lot of explanation." Similarly here, I use the term execution to refer to the set of features they chose which led to success. I did not feel that it was vital to the point I was trying to make to specify which features specifically.
Re:Who Cares If It's Been Tried Before? by jacquesm on Monday April 22, 2013 @05:49PM (#5591965)
Way to pull 'that part of my statement' out of context. It says (and I think that's a pretty clear bit):

> If there was some other factor why a venture failed and it wasn't timing then it does not even count.

Clearly, if your execution sucks then timing wasn't the factor.

Re:Who Cares If It's Been Tried Before? by chacham15 on Monday April 22, 2013 @06:59PM (#5592251)
> If there was some other factor why a venture failed and it wasn't timing then it does not even count

Thats a misleading idea because it suggests that execution and timing are separable. Who is to say that some company failed because the timing was wrong or because their execution was bad? Furthermore, couldnt it be both? As Drew Houston said, he had to convince people that he was solving a problem that they didnt even know that they had! What I am trying to show here is that Drew created his market, he didnt wait for the right time when people had this problem that they so desperately needed solved. He made them realize it himself. Chalking things up to just timing belittles the efforts put forth by the founders.

Re:Who Cares If It's Been Tried Before? by nitrogen on Monday April 22, 2013 @10:55PM (#5593057)
I must disagree, in light of ChuckMcM's comment (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5592391). Though saying "timing is everything" may belittle the efforts of the founders who succeeded, saying "execution is everything" gives the successful founders too much credit, and the researchers, the also-rans, and the market too little.