News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook tries Google's WebP image format; users squawk by w1ntermute on Monday April 22, 2013 @12:25PM (#5590144)
> Because they broke the web for their users.

No, they didn't. The web works fine. They can browse it without any issues. The problems occur when they're trying to do stuff on their local machines.

> Not for users, no. The only gain here is facebook's bandwidth costs, at the expense (and inconvenience) of its users.

Change rarely occurs smoothly.

Re:Facebook tries Google's WebP image format; users squawk by jterce on Monday April 22, 2013 @12:47PM (#5590288)
> The problems occur when they're trying to do stuff on their local machines.

By all means, try to explain that to users if you like, and if you think they'd care. The issue is that it breaks the user experience, whatever technical reason you'd like to attribute that to.

Re:Facebook tries Google's WebP image format; users squawk by w1ntermute on Monday April 22, 2013 @12:51PM (#5590319)
I'm not explaining anything to the users, I'm just explaining to you how you're wrong when you state that they "broke the web for their users".

The users are completely irrelevant, because no matter how much they bitch and moan, they're not going to leave Facebook. Its network effects are too powerful. And so, for once, I actually support Facebook. They're using their dominant market position to push a new standard that is quite good. This will hopefully force companies like Adobe to start adding support for WebP by default. Then we'll finally able to ditch obsolete standards like JPEG and its ilk once and for all.

Re:Facebook tries Google's WebP image format; users squawk by lelandbatey on Monday April 22, 2013 @03:28PM (#5591283)
This is one of those times where changing something breaks somebody's work flow because they're doing things outside of spec. And in cases like this, you have to say "get over it."

Facebook is still doing what Facebook intends to do, in fact they do it better! It's unfortunate that a tiny margin of users are slightly inconvenienced, but they need to get over it.