Re:Grad Student Who Took Down Reinhart and Rogoff Explains W...
by carbocation on Monday April 22, 2013 @12:19PM
(#5590101)
Fox News is not in the business of science. I used the term "related fields" as a euphemism for Econ and Psych because I didn't want to get drawn into a demarcation debate.
Wherever the line is drawn, the dishonesty of some random Fox News chart is not related to the honesty or dishonesty of actual scientific research.
The much bigger problem in science is error.
Re:Grad Student Who Took Down Reinhart and Rogoff Explains W...
by niggler on Monday April 22, 2013 @12:42PM
(#5590263)
" didn't want to get drawn into a demarcation debate."
Econ and Psych really do lie in a gray area, and by avoid the demarcation debate you completely miss the relevance of the issue at hand.
If policy makers weren't using this study to justify more austerity, then we probably wouldn't have such a prolonged discussion.
Re:Grad Student Who Took Down Reinhart and Rogoff Explains W...
by jerf on Monday April 22, 2013 @12:19PM
(#5590102)
Distorting the truth about the state of the economy is not something confined to one partisan side, and the need for data transparency extends beyond economics regardless.
But we are talking about economics, and republican groups like fox news eat it up.
My favorite example is the 2011 chart distorting the display of the unemployment rate:
http://mediamatters.org/blog/2011/12/12/today-in-dishonest-f...