This is a prime example of how QS is supposed to work. Many people talk about deliberate practice, but the truth is, you can't practice deliberately unless you are tracking what you want to change. Of course, the other half of deliberate practice is knowing the most effective way to induce change, but much like in programming, how do you know it is working if you aren't tracking/testing it? Temet nosce.
But when I started tracking I found that while my overall weight wasn't changing, my percentage of body fat was dropping, indicating that I was in fact gaining muscle. It's not like this was technically new information, but seeing the numbers triggered some sort of response in me which made it very easy to keep going to the gym.