News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facial Recognition Failed in Boston Bombing by kevincennis on Sunday April 21, 2013 @11:18AM (#5585094)
It seems disingenuous to say that facial recognition failed. As far as I can tell, all the images we had of these suspects were either very low-resolution, taken from angles, or both. Seems plausible that law enforcement didn't have any good candidate images from which to run a facial recognition search.

> In the end it was mostly dumb luck

What? Painstaking police work went in to getting images of these suspects, and the release of those photos are almost certainly what led to Thursday's events and, ultimately, the killing and capture of the suspects.

> the city lockdown failed (the guy smoking the cigarette outside when he saw the blood was technically violating the lockdown)

Firstly, the lockdown is what forced suspect #2 to hide out in a boat instead of fleeing the area. Secondly, and less importantly, the guy smoking a cigarette wasn't violating the lockdown. It had ended prior to him going outside.

Was there luck involved? Of course. But there was also tremendous work done by a number of law enforcement agencies - without which, the suspects may never have been killed and captured.

Re:Facial Recognition Failed in Boston Bombing by ck2 on Sunday April 21, 2013 @12:06PM (#5585259)
The brothers didn't leave the area, didn't go into hiding and were able to kill a campus officer and hijack a car, all without police finding them for a week.

It was mostly dumb luck. It's not like they were hiding!

Oh, and http://boston.cbslocal.com/2013/03/27/hanover-police-trying-...

Re:Facial Recognition Failed in Boston Bombing by kevincennis on Sunday April 21, 2013 @12:19PM (#5585294)
They didn't go into hiding or leave because they didn't think they needed to. It seems pretty clear they they didn't want to be caught.

From what I can tell, numerous people called in after the photos were released. Even if Thursday's events hadn't taken place, the police would have known the identities of both suspects shortly thereafter.

It just seems crazy to me not to acknowledge the role of investigators in all of this and chock it up to luck.

As for the edit you just made about the bombs in Hanover: are you implying there's a link to the Marathon bombers? Seems like conspiracy theory reaching - unless there's some sort of evidence you'd like to share.

Re:Facial Recognition Failed in Boston Bombing by sliverstorm on Sunday April 21, 2013 @07:45PM (#5586962)
It just seems crazy to me not to acknowledge the role of investigators in all of this and chock it up to luck

People do crazy things when they have made up their minds before the story even begins.

Re:Facial Recognition Failed in Boston Bombing by anigbrowl on Sunday April 21, 2013 @04:10PM (#5586223)
The brothers didn't leave the area, didn't go into hiding and were able to kill a campus officer and hijack a car, all without police finding them for a week.

I know you dislike law enforcement in general, but such casual exaggeration isn't helping your case. As of today, it's only 6 days since the bombings took place. The bombings happened late on a Monday morning. By Thursday evening, there were photos and videos of the suspects all over the media. There's a good chance that that's what flushed them out of cover.

Re:Facial Recognition Failed in Boston Bombing by ryanhuff on Sunday April 21, 2013 @06:05PM (#5586636)
You are wrong. We know that the younger brother returned to his school 60 miles away from the bombing, and was seen at his school partying it up the day before the MIT officer was killed. Please get your facts straight.
Re:Facial Recognition Failed in Boston Bombing by openmx on Sunday April 21, 2013 @09:02PM (#5587221)
Where do you get a week from? It was 3 days.
Re:Facial Recognition Failed in Boston Bombing by ajdecon on Sunday April 21, 2013 @02:36PM (#5585821)
> It seems disingenuous to say that facial recognition failed. As far as I can tell, all the images we had of these suspects were either very low-resolution, taken from angles, or both. Seems plausible that law enforcement didn't have any good candidate images from which to run a facial recognition search.

"Failed" might be too strong, but I'd definitely say it's not yet ready for deployment.

My impression is that the Boston marathon was extremely well-photographed from a variety of angles, by everything from nearby security cameras to folks in the crowd. This seems like the best kind of data set you'd reasonably expect outside a controlled environment (i.e., a lab or security checkpoint). If it's not yet good enough to at least flag possible matches based on this data, I'm not sure I believe it's ready for widespread use.

Re:Facial Recognition Failed in Boston Bombing by lttlrck on Sunday April 21, 2013 @06:56PM (#5586827)
It wasn't a lockdown, it was 'shelter in place'.