News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A new search engine by joedevon on Saturday April 20, 2013 @03:42AM (#5580694)
"I'm skeptical you'll achieve what you aim for if you're way off the mark in understanding how Google is so successful."

Considering his comment drew out Matt Cutts, I'd bet he understands Google pretty well.

Re:A new search engine by danso on Saturday April 20, 2013 @03:55AM (#5580718)
Right, but the success of a technical product is often based on results that can be tested and verified, and less on arguments through authority, though if Cutts is willing to say something like. "Wow, the OP has created something that surpasses Google in [whatever metric]", I'd admit I'd take his word on it.

But the OP's claim stands on its own and makes assertions that can easily be verified. Are you arguing that Google's search engine is as simple and literal as the OP claims?

Re:A new search engine by drakaal on Saturday April 20, 2013 @04:04AM (#5580733)
Google Brandon Wirtz Greatest Living American. I am pretty good at understanding how Google works.

While Google gets things right with out all of our language stuff a lot of that is because they have user data about what people are clicking on and which things they come back after reading.

That data means if they can get the stuff on to the front page they can "crowd source" the rest.

We don't have that user base for a feed back loop. We have to get our results entirely based on software.

Re:A new search engine by joedevon on Sunday April 21, 2013 @02:48PM (#5585866)
Not that it's as simple and literal, just that he purposely oversimplified it for the purposes of his comment.

It's not like he was writing up this big detailed blog post.