News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A new search engine by danso on Saturday April 20, 2013 @03:31AM (#5580676)
I will happily concede that you and your colleagues know more about search than I will ever know, and so I find it strange that we're having this argument...your perception of Google's limitations seems so far off that it's as if you've mistakenly referred to them instead of AltaVista.

To answer your questions, yes and yes, Google can derive the meaning of my search without relying on literal interpretation of the search terms. In fact, Google can return what I want even if I deliberately spell every word in the query incorrectly:

"couk besr ribz" instead of "cook best ribs" brings up recipes of how to do good ribs:

https://www.google.com/search?q=couk+besr+ribz

I'm willing to take you at your word, that there is a better way to interpret context and meaning from a search query than however Google does it...but if that is the entire raison d'etre for your search engine, can you come up with at least a few case examples where this is the case? The "cupcakes" you've contrived is clearly hypothetical (and not at all close to what happens in reality), and the ones that I've tried don't seem to show any improvement on human-friendly results. Which is not to say that samuru is a bad product...what you claim to do is incredibly difficult and is exactly the feature that makes Google such a useful, ubiquitous engine...I would love to be surprised but I'm skeptical that a new engine with a fraction of Google's processing power, nevermind the resources for test engineering and algorithm design, can compete with Google here...this isn't a "well, why hasn't anyone ranked search queries in this way before?" in the same way that PageRank/BackRub was 15 years ago...Search engines have been analyzing queries for intent, and their shortcomings in this area are due to it being a very hard problem, and not for lack of desire.

Re:A new search engine by DanBC on Saturday April 20, 2013 @03:43AM (#5580696)
Your Google link gives me "Searching for couk best ribs".

The 10 results give me:

2 hits for boat related stuff, with no food.

4 hits for restaurants, with no recipes.

1 hit about cervical ribs.

And then, in positions 5, 8, and 9 there are recipes.

So, even with all the smart people and computing power at Google this is still a very hard problem.

It's great to have different people trying different approaches.

Re:A new search engine by danso on Saturday April 20, 2013 @03:49AM (#5580705)
That's strange, I get links from amazingribs.com and food.com, which is more or less what I expect

http://www.amazingribs.com/recipes/porknography/best_BBQ_rib...

Either way, it's a deliberately contrived example to show that Google was more sophisticated than the GP indicates...I have no comment on whether amazingribs.com really does have the best ribs preparation tips

Re:A new search engine by drakaal on Saturday April 20, 2013 @04:01AM (#5580727)
Hover over the Samuru Logo on the results. We will tell you a bit about what kind of search we think you are doing.

http://www.samuru.com/?q=python+list+comprehension

While we get the same top result for this, we also show that WikiHow.com linked to the Python Docs. So you can see closely related articles grouped together.

This is useful for things like http://www.samuru.com/?q=samsung+apple+patent+press+release

But Google requires the words or the synonyms to be on the results page. So do we, but we know that a search for http://www.samuru.com/?q=cook+bbq+ribs is not just about how to make BBQ Ribs, but to make the best BBQ ribs, because this is a subjective topic, I like honey BBQ, someone else likes Mesquite. That factors in to our results.

Re:A new search engine by saintx on Saturday April 20, 2013 @10:35AM (#5581526)
I repeated the experiment and got different results than yours. (woot, science!)

http://imgur.com/ghYKH7K shows my results. I can't reproduce the ones you describe.

Regional variations might account for the differences. Do you live in a place where people don't eat ribs? (If so, please accept my sincere condolences)