News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:50 years of bad grammar advice by tokenadult on Saturday April 11, 2009 @06:57PM (#557920)
Geoffrey Pullum

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geoffrey_Pullum

knows what he is talking about.

"What concerns me is that the bias against the passive is being retailed by a pair of authors so grammatically clueless that they don't know what is a passive construction and what isn't. Of the four pairs of examples offered to show readers what to avoid and how to correct it, a staggering three out of the four are mistaken diagnoses. 'At dawn the crowing of a rooster could be heard' is correctly identified as a passive clause, but the other three are all errors:

"* 'There were a great number of dead leaves lying on the ground' has no sign of the passive in it anywhere.

"* 'It was not long before she was very sorry that she had said what she had' also contains nothing that is even reminiscent of the passive construction.

"* 'The reason that he left college was that his health became impaired' is presumably fingered as passive because of 'impaired,' but that's a mistake. It's an adjective here. 'Become' doesn't allow a following passive clause. (Notice, for example, that 'A new edition became issued by the publishers' is not grammatical.)"

I agree with Pullum that one of the big problems of Strunk and White as a guide to writing is its nearly complete ignorance of discourse structure or any other level of analysis beyond looking at single sentences.

Re:50 years of bad grammar advice by frossie on Saturday April 11, 2009 @07:32PM (#557943)
I don't want to comment on the grammatical correctness, being a non-native English speaker, but on the subject of the passive in general I can safely say I sure wouldn't mind some code to screen it out of our bug reporting system. Quite often the primary response is "The reason this is happening is because of X. X should be modified to trap this" or some such. Invariably, I have to enquire "so who will fix X and when are they likely to do it"? The passive construction has been used to mean "I will fix X now", "I would fix X but I am not going to", "I am addressing this to Joe, and I naturally assume that he will understand that he is supposed to fix X along the lines I described".
Re:50 years of bad grammar advice by gruseom on Sunday April 12, 2009 @03:17AM (#558256)
The issue here is that people are evading responsibility, not that they are using the passive voice to do it (though the passive voice is notoriously handy for this purpose).
Re:50 years of bad grammar advice by frossie on Sunday April 12, 2009 @01:14PM (#558638)
No, there is no conscious evasion of responsibility. The person who writes the response thinks they are saying "I will fix it" or "I am telling X to fix it" and the passive voice is consistent with what they think they are saying. It is just hard for anyone else to figure that out without being mindreaders.

This is particularly common in people with academic background, as the passive voice is often encouraged in scientific writing.

Re:50 years of bad grammar advice by 10ren on Saturday April 11, 2009 @07:39PM (#557951)
I'm seeing a connection between passive/active and declarative/imperative.