Re:Debate HN: Is Bitcoin a currency or a commodity?
by Piskvorrr on Thursday April 18, 2013 @09:14AM
(#5570382)
Being protected by law doesn't help it any - many currencies have failed despite such protections. The volatility is the real issue; as long as the value fluctuates wildly, it won't be useful as currency (and vice versa!).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Debate HN: Is Bitcoin a currency or a commodity?
by legitsource on Thursday April 18, 2013 @09:28AM
(#5570439)
If it becomes more widely accepted to purchase tangible goods and services, do you think the value will continue to swing wildly?
In some aspects, I would think that would moderate the pricing, since at the moment it's not good for that much else for most people other than speculation and cashing in/out as needed.
Re:Debate HN: Is Bitcoin a currency or a commodity?
by ProblemFactory on Thursday April 18, 2013 @02:03PM
(#5572076)
Yes - but only if the merchants set fixed prices in bitcoin, rather than "$20 USD, transferred via bitcoin". Which they won't be able to do until their suppliers, employees and taxes can be paid in fixed number of bitcoins.
More merchants via instant-USD-conversion will certainly increase the popularity of bitcoin, but won't help at all in giving it a moderate value in tangible goods and services.