The original is 95 characters. "design that’s " and two comma's in the numbers get dropped and we're down to exactly 78.
Dropping words from a title in order to fit the 80 char limit is a bit of an art if you don't want to change the meaning, and making a new title is frowned upon because then you care not using the original title. Effectively you can't post an article with a title > 80 characters and not break the rules.
I never knew that. Thanks for the heads-up. I find it annoying that people rewrite headlines, but I didn't realize there was an actual reason.
GGP says
> copy the article's title, do not invent your own.
Unfortunately you can't always do that. Dropping words is one technique to shorten the title, rewriting it is another, both techniques are employed.
"New Li+ battery design - 2,000x more powerful, recharges 1,000x faster"
Now you just have to know that Li is Lithium and the + is for an ion.
> "New Li+ battery design - 2,000x more powerful, recharges 1,000x faster"
In that spirit (and just for fun): "New Li+ battery design - 2k x more power, charges 1k x faster.
I originally tried scientific numeric notation, but that didn't actually shorten the title: 2x10^3 versus 2,000. :(
That sounds like a battery to me. The new design has actually been built and tested. The quote you pulled out refers to scaling it up to things like lasers and F1 cars. A button-sized battery sounds fine for a lot of electronics today. Just not an F1 car.
Yield probably is low, and the current process will likely be way too labour intensive.
True technological innovation needs not just engineering feasibility but also economic feasibility. I'm not trying to say that the research that "dead ends" is pointless. Progress is progress. All I am trying to say is that it doesn't mean economic viability is right around the corner.
Often, researchers are well aware of scaling or manufacturing hurdles when they embark on the experiments. For the sake of academic careers and exposure, the research will get hyped regardless of the viability of implementing the research.
Yes, but guess what? That's true -- it's not a marketable product, it's a laboratory curiosity. That difference mustn't be dismissed. There are any number of research developments that never become products for reasons other than their theoretical properties.
> Isn't that how bleeding-edge innovation works?
Not exactly. If if were, a solar panel that converted a higher percentage of the sun's energy into electricity would beat a panel that produced more power per dollar. But in reality, it's the other way around.
Not when the public thinks a battery is something you can buy for a reasonable price. This reminds me of the solar panel business, where the driving market issue is not cell efficiency, it's cell cost per watt. A panel that produces more watts per dollar will usually beat a panel that's more efficient at capturing the sun's energy.
Maybe a decade ago there was a fad of sticking a bare, unbiased LED across a button cell and relying on the internal resistance of the cell to current limit the LED. Then you superglue a magnet on it and toss it and you've got a LED throwie. If you tried that with a super low internal resistance battery like this, the effect would be vaguely similar to sticking the LED across a power outlet (boom).
This submission's title: "New lithium-ion battery 2000 times more powerful, recharges 1000 times faster"
The actual title: "New lithium-ion battery design that’s 2,000 times more powerful, recharges 1,000 times faster"
The missing word is "design", a word that is crucial to the meaning of the article. The article discusses a design for a battery, not a battery. How important is that? Here's the last sentence in the linked article:
"For this to occur, though, the University of Illinois will first have to prove that their technology scales to larger battery sizes, and that the production process isn’t prohibitively expensive for commercial production."
It's a design, not a battery.
The solution to this problem, as I have pointed out many times before, is to copy the article's title, do not invent your own.