News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:19-year-old auctioned off 10 percent of her salary for 10... by ryusage on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @06:42PM (#5561438)
That seems a little over dramatic...

If anything, this is a decent-sized loan, with a very safe, variable repayment amount that is defined to always be a small amount of her income, and the collateral is a company that may or may not succeed. More than that, the investor only even takes the company if she's dishonest. There's almost no downside for her here.

If you want to be concerned for someone, I'd be concerned about the investor.

Re:19-year-old auctioned off 10 percent of her salary for 10... by jacalata on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @06:56PM (#5561485)
He doesn't say 'this is slavery'. So, which of the points listed would have to fail for you to consider this concerning? If she was only getting $10,000? If the variable repayment was 50% or 90% of her salary, or a fixed small or large amount per year? If the investor got the company if the 10% over 10 years did not meet some minimum amount? Never?
Re:19-year-old auctioned off 10 percent of her salary for 10... by seanalltogether on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @07:09PM (#5561536)
The point is to take legal scenarios like this and see how far they can be pushed. What if her parents were the ones auctioning her potential earnings off and using the money to pay of a mortgage. What if the following year they did it again for another 10%? Things get really sketchy when you draw up these kinds of contracts that revolve solely around an individual.
Re:19-year-old auctioned off 10 percent of her salary for 10... by ryusage on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @04:14PM (#5566856)
Okay, so you're suggesting this seems to set a dangerous legal precedent with slippery slope potential? I still say it's just a loan. To your argument here, can her parents legally take out loans in her name? I don't actually know the law there, but I don't think a lawyer would have a hard time answering that.

To your earlier question about 51% or 100% of her salary, if an investor loans me $500,000 at 0% interest to pay back in 10 years, and I only make $50,000/yr, that would suck, but I'm not becoming a slave to that investor. I can't afford to pay that back, so I'm going to default on my loan. There's a huge difference between that and literally being owned by someone.