Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There...
by alex_stoddard on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @02:44PM
(#5559986)
A new journal http://f1000research.com/ has a really interesting new take on this: post-publication, transparent peer-review.
You should see how bad it is in my field of study - biomechanics. It's a pure black box. We have total cronyism, where one reviewer has disproportional power since he was the first to publish much of the modern stuff. Therefore, people will do anything to have him review their papers, and his papers are pushed through despite what many feel are seriously glaring errors in methodology and collection.
This is the walled garden crap that turns me off to "peer-reviewed research."