For a pure functional language, like Haskell, speculatively evaluating pieces of it in parallel shouldn't hurt anything (since they are guaranteed not to have side effects).
It is my understanding that the lazy semantics of Haskell mostly mean that you shouldn't be making any assumptions about the order of evaluation which would seem to be useful from an optimization perspective.
I am still new to FP and Haskell, so please correct me if I am misinterpreting things.
A crudely example, to impart some intuition:
True || this_crashes();
Imagine the above reliance on lazy semantics, but then for Haskell memory management or constructs such as infinite lists.The semantics of your program rely on the fact that some branches of your AST/program are not visited, due to lazy semantics. A FP with eager evaluation semantics can be free to evaluate every branch of the program, throwing away what isn't used. Lazy evaluation means a runtime cannot be as aggressive, introducing a number of logical sequence points.
NB. A Haskell colleague lets me know that it is considered good style in Haskell these days to program as if it was eagerly evaluated. There is talk of limiting or doing away with it in Haskell Prime. Can anyone confirm/deny this?
[True, SpinForever()]
You can consider any "variable" in Haskell to have a value of the type of that variable or the bottom value. The bottom value is tech-speak for no-value at all, since it means that the program has gone into a infinite-loop trying to produce the value.Eagerness would fix this since, such a program as above would always cause a infinite-loop, and thus the program would no longer be a useful construction. While with lazy evaluation it only spins if you try to evaluate any more than the first element in the list.
Of course you could also fix this by going with total programming which basically removes the implicit bottom-value from the language. Which is a nice concept. Though then you need to explicitly declare you infinite data from you finite data (think a network socket, compared with string). And you lose Turing-completeness (but who needs that anyway :) )
That kind of code is only valid in strict languages because of short circuiting, is functionally equivalent to lazyness in this respect. If you tried to automatically parallelize C by speculatively evaluating both sides you would have exactly the same problem.
Lazy languages may make this kind of code easier to write, but the problem is actually that of non-deterministic calculations, and would be a problem anywhere.
That's not functional though--this_crashes() has side effects. I'm far from a Haskell expert, but I guess in practice you'd be returning some error type from that function, and it didn't matter whether it's evaluated or not, since True || arbitrary_expression will always just be True.
Laziness, AFAIK, only complicates compilation due to making it hard to reason about memory/performance, and for having branches all over to see if expressions have been evaluated yet.
> True || construct_a_1TB_object()
Unless you have infinite computation and memory, there are always visible side-effects, no matter how functional your language is.
If the 1TB object can in any way be constructed a bit at a time, then in principle you can get some work done in constructing it and back that out if you wind up not needing it.
If you're interested, someone already did some legwork on this, using an eager version of Haskell:
[1] S. Aditya, Arvind, J.-W. Maessen, L. Augustsson, and R. S. Nikhil, “Semantics of pH: A parallel dialect of Haskell,” presented at the FPCA 95, 1995, pp. 35–49.
Roughly, graph reduction execution represents an expression as a node, with an edge to nodes of subexpressions. A value of a node is obtained by walking through it's children, setting the value of each node as the recursion winds down. String reduction simply modifies the expression itself. This does not eliminate common subexpressions (a() * a() will reduce a() twice), which is why graph reduction is favoured. In a parallel world, you often don't care about the extra work if it reduces the number of synchronisation.
As the FP community has consolidated around Haskell, this usually refers to the Haskell feature set: Graph reduction, lazy semantics. Graph reduction is extremely imperative (see: spineless stackless g-machine), which makes it map well on a Von Neumann processor, but limits the amount of exploitable parallelism. Relying on lazy semantics also wrecks parallelism, because some evaluation branches cannot be visited ahead of time, without changing the program's semantics.
A functional language using eager semantics and string-reduction execution would map much better on, say, a parallel dataflow processor. Research in this direction got buried as parallel research money evaporated in the early 90's