Re:Women, Tech Conferences and the Bullshit Surrounding It
by j_s on Monday April 15, 2013 @03:30PM
(#5553683)
I never did follow up to see how DjangoCon 2013 turned out... looks like you're about right.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5036457
> Everybody can vote for DjangoCon 2013 presentations (Github required)
> The voting is deliberately anonymous at this first stage.
Re:Women, Tech Conferences and the Bullshit Surrounding It
by juridatenshi on Monday April 15, 2013 @03:28PM
(#5553670)
Blinding combined with active outreach to get more people to submit to a CFP has helped several conferences improve their numbers. GoGaRuCo is the one that immediately comes to mind.
Re:Women, Tech Conferences and the Bullshit Surrounding It
by theoretick on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @03:54AM
(#5556842)
I have sat on organizational committees and name-blinding would not work for some of us for one key reason: We use speaker's name/identity as a criteria for talk selection. Two main examples are whether they have presented before and how "strong" of a speaker they are.
We DO use names to discriminate but that often allows us to have "fresh" speakers and keep the lineup somewhat varied. It also allows us to filter for all the other spam-talks; i.e. marketers.
It is an issue of priorities but I would easily place quality of presentations over guaranteed blinding to prevent gender-bias selection.
Re:Women, Tech Conferences and the Bullshit Surrounding It
by sliverstorm on Monday April 15, 2013 @03:21PM
(#5553620)
This boils down to the age-old question; "equitable vs. equal".
If you name-blind the review process you would still expect to get 95% men unless there is a higher % of women submitting talks and being rejected because they are women.
The quoted article suggests doing the opposite of name-blinding and actively looking for female talks in the pile.