News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How much usage can a Lego piece take before it loses its ... by martin-adams on Monday April 15, 2013 @02:36PM (#5553282)
After 4 days 6 hours it did 36,720 iterations. After 10 days it failed on 37,112 iterations.

It takes 10 seconds per iteration. My calculations say it would have failed after 4 days and 7 hours. I wonder what happened to the other 5 and a half days.

Very cool experiment. It's this type of testing that makes me feel reassured in mechanical engineering. It's about reassuring that a car air bag will work after years of inactivity, or a car seat belt buckle will not break under pressure in a collision. The only way to know is to test, test, test.

Re:How much usage can a Lego piece take before it loses its ... by pcantin on Monday April 15, 2013 @07:59PM (#5555312)
I'm the guy that built it: During the tests, I had to guess the current count based on the estimate that one full iteration was about 10 seconds. This was not a good estimate and it made me overshot the actual number. When the test was finally over I was able to see on the SD-card the final 'real' total of 37,112. I'm making a new video explaining some of this.
Re:How much usage can a Lego piece take before it loses its ... by officialjunk on Monday April 15, 2013 @09:30PM (#5555633)
Honest question: do you think it matters that the bricks are attached with a radial motion rather than linear? From my personal usage, I tend to press all areas down at the same time rather than one side fully contacting before the other. I would imagine the wear is different between these two cases.
Re:How much usage can a Lego piece take before it loses its ... by pcantin on Monday April 15, 2013 @10:01PM (#5555721)
You're right and this is why I intend to build a better rig. More answers in this new vid I just uploaded: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VLt8HkIOAuY
Re:How much usage can a Lego piece take before it loses its ... by gvb on Monday April 15, 2013 @10:18PM (#5555790)
I like your plan of testing LEGO bricks[1] from different eras, but I would recommend you use the same rotary mechanism for all the tests. If you change the mechanism to a linear one, you won't be able to compare with confidence the first (rotary) test with any follow-on linear actuator tests.

OTOH, if you repeat the (rotary) 70's era test with the linear actuator, that would be interesting estimate of whether a rotary actuation is better or worse for the brick longevity. Of course, you will still have a sample size of one, so your confidence interval will be meaningless. I can see this turning into a lifelong obsession... ;-)

[1] http://aboutus.lego.com/en-us/legal-notice/fair-play/

Re:How much usage can a Lego piece take before it loses its ... by pcantin on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @05:25AM (#5557126)
Once I have a new test machine that his much faster I will indeed retest all the eras (with multiple tests per era). Of course this time I plan to build a real sound proofing system around it. This last machine was really annoying.
Re:How much usage can a Lego piece take before it loses its ... by fryguy on Monday April 15, 2013 @10:11PM (#5555755)
Do you think you could perhaps make it faster by doing computer vision and making the mechanism go up-down only and not waiting for the sensor, and then checking the photo while it moves?
Re:How much usage can a Lego piece take before it loses its ... by pcantin on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @05:28AM (#5557140)
The sensor was not the slowest element, it was the servos combined with the design. For the next build I plan to use a big step-motor rotating in continuous mode and transfer the rotation motion into a linear one like steam powered machines do.
Re:How much usage can a Lego piece take before it loses its ... by Crake on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @02:06AM (#5556534)
Ooh, good question!
Re:How much usage can a Lego piece take before it loses its ... by Crake on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @02:05AM (#5556531)
Congratulations, sir. I just about lost my shit laughing when I saw the arduino in the first picture. Good work, it's really cool seeing people doing interesting projects like this. The maximum number of lego presses is something I might never have thought of (I'm a k'nex person!), but I'm really happy to now know.
Re:How much usage can a Lego piece take before it loses its ... by acrooks on Monday April 15, 2013 @04:38PM (#5554172)
I think the 10 day figure included the time it took to build the machine.
Re:How much usage can a Lego piece take before it loses its ... by tnorthcutt on Monday April 15, 2013 @03:44PM (#5553789)
After 4 days 6 hours it did 36,720 iterations. After 10 days it failed on 37,112 iterations.

I noticed that inconsistency as well.