Re:My Objection to Array#sum
by jerf on Thursday April 09, 2009 @05:56PM
(#555245)
I anticipated this objection if you go back and re-read my post, but I'll blow out the point a bit more here: In Java terms, "sequence" is an interface.
You can't put join there. Because then you have to put add, any, none, all, reduce, filter, and so on and so forth for at least another ten or twenty base methods (ignoring everything else that applies just to the sequence protocol written by users), which every single implementation would then have to provide. No matter how abstractly beautiful it may be that this implements object-orientation dogma, in practice it's an idea too stupid to even begin to consider.
You can't put join there. Because then you have to put add, any, none, all, reduce, filter, and so on and so forth for at least another ten or twenty base methods (ignoring everything else that applies just to the sequence protocol written by users), which every single implementation would then have to provide. No matter how abstractly beautiful it may be that this implements object-orientation dogma, in practice it's an idea too stupid to even begin to consider.