Yes, I too have had to sort through pages of various SEO keyword-spam to find what I'm looking for, but the connection from there to this poor example to the number of extraneous elements on a website to accusing Google of having forged a broken web is, well, weak.
However, it is not as if pdftohtml is obscure. It is a common component of a great number of GNU/Linux distributions and has been for many years. So setting aside the merits of the top result, the lower results are still problematic.
Unlike the top result, neither Pdftohtml nor the high ranking results are SaaS - they're downloads for offline use. What differentiates them is their value propositions. They are in opposition between Google and the lay person and the results are caveat emptor solely for Google's benefit.
Elsewhere, I have used a better example, "weather". The top results are advertising revenue driven. The best result? In most cases, the National Weather Service point data - advertising free, updated regularly, and generated by Phd meteorologists, not pretty faces for TV.
In this case, Pdftohtml shows the way in which Google drives us toward online rather than offline solutions. It drives us away from using our CPU cycles and towards consuming bandwidth, and absent that toward tools which pay for advertising.
The service you used was monetized. It just didn't charge you a fee. Instead, it will seek to charge someone else a fee later for data about you. Free doesn't mean "public service."
And still, the Yellow Pages were successful because they were helpful. People liked using them, so businesses were happy to pay for better exposure.
> The service you used was monetized. It just didn't charge you a fee. Instead, it will seek to charge someone else a fee later for data about you. You didn't use a charity.
It's not clear why I should care? They provided me with a valuable service (or they might have been, I was just testing it out), if they can get paid for that, good for them. They didn't ask for any information from me, contact or otherwise, so I doubt the value for resale is very high.
Monetization depends on lack of awareness first and the bother of dealing with ubiquitous attempts at data mining second. Care or care not. There is no should.
Google merely made a very successful business out of making businesses willing to pay up slightly easier to find, roughly like the yellow pages did.
Finally, on your "convert PDF to HTML" example: My first hit is PDFOnline.com, that has a nice, green button labeled "upload". When I use that button to upload a PDF document, the site generates a HTML document for me. It was quick, easy and it didn't ask for money. Totally passable for the top result for the query.
pdftohtml was the fourth link - hardly outrageous for a terse, technically worded page. Oh and that Windows version (helpfully referred to as a "win32 GUI", because nobody calls it "windows" anyway) that it linked to? The link is dead.