And managers turn over long-term investor portfolios quickly. The average holding period for an SP500 company shareholder is 100 days.
And every time a trade happens you run the risk of getting clipped by the faster guys who see you coming.
I think it is natural, but fallacious, to apply line-of-sight properties to trading. If you plan to trade, then there are two ways that another participant can "see you coming": 1. If you don't have direct market access, your order gets routed through a broker. The broker sees your order before it hits the market, and if he jumps in line ahead of you then that is front-running, and a Bad Thing. Your broker can get in a lot of trouble for this sort of thing. 2. If you are trying to move a large position by sending multiple orders to the market (one after another), then all market participants have the chance to react to the first order. It's really a game to try to move a lot of inventory at once, without tipping your hand to anyone else in the room. Thems the breaks. Nobody else gets to see anyone's order before the matching engine has already processed it, so there's no way to jump "ahead" of it.
OTOH, maybe your long-term investor is trying to time the market: wait for a signal intraday, and pick that moment to send an order. In that case, if it is a good intraday signal then it is likely that someone else will compete. It is unlikely for a long-term trader to have spent as much on infrastructure as a HF trader, so the juicy signals will result in missed executions that _look_ like front-running.
1. VWAP based trading of large positions, which creates assymetric momentum effects in volume and price (and which is then somewhat forecastable)
2. Not then recognizing that you are forecastable (as a result of playing the VWAP game). The extra information that someone who looks at intraday price relationships has over someone who doesn't. If you wade into the middle of a market that is short-run forecastable (eg it's trending downwards to a new level and the market maker/HFT guys are battling their battles), and you don't check as to whether it's short-run forecastable, then you're probably the patzy at the poker table.
Why would short term investing be bad, and how long do you think HFT algorithms hold their "investments"?
I hope you're not just trying to blow smoke up my ass here.
Short term investing is "bad" because you're not investing in the future success of the company you're trading on the basis of what you think the market is going to do. To the extent to which that is ever knowable it is unlikely you have the skill, experience and data to be able to beat the large number of professionals doing it.
> The HFT trader
You say it like it's a person making trades.
> I've benefited because I can buy/sell at a price close to the quoted exchange price, which didn't use to be the case.
What's a "quoted exchange price" if it's not the price you actually pay?
> Short term investing is "bad" because you're not investing in the future success of the company you're trading on the basis of what you think the market is going to do.
Isn't this what HFT is all about?
Trading on insider information is bad, of course. But if you're on a level playing field, I don't see anything wrong with profiting from something you correctly predicted short-term.
The actual price you have to pay is based on how much you want to buy and how much other people are willing to sell at what price.
People who want to buy give a "bid" price and people who want to sell give an "ask" price. Whenever there is an ask price that is lower than a bid price, a sale takes place. This results in the lowest ask price always being higher than the highest bid price. The quoted exchange price will be somewhere in between the two prices.
If you want to sell right away, the most you can get is the highest bid price on the books. If you want to buy right away, the cheapest you can get it is the lowest bid price on the books. This means that you have to pay more than the quoted exchange price to buy and receive less than the quoted exchange price to sell.
The quoted exchange price is an average of the buy/sell offers available, there is no guarantee if you try and trade that you will pay that amount. Especially if you are shifting large blocks of stock.
There is nothing wrong with "short term predicting" but it isn't investing. It is often a very easy way to lose money, "bad" doesn't just mean morally so. It comes down to time horizons, how much you want to make, and how many people are also trying to predict that event. You can correctly predict that event and still not make money as it is already priced in.
The mean of the bid and the ask, generally. For a daily close price it can be a fifteen-or-so minute average thereof.
Long term investing isn't affected by HFT, except in providing more liquidity at the point you want to exit any position. If you're planning on holding for 5+ years you're competing against relatively few people and can do good research. Any shorter timeframe and you're competing against millions, against computers and against unknowables that will distort the price in the short term.