News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Rent Seeking Economy by rayiner on Monday April 15, 2013 @12:20AM (#5549710)
That utterly misconceives both the nature of spectrum and the nature of property rights. Every property right is a government construct--there are no such things as "rights" in the statute of nature.[1] As far as property rights go, spectrum is much more like land than it is like information. A property right in land isn't just ownership of the physical dirt--it's ownership of a particular piece of a finite coordinate space. Similarly, spectrum rights are ownership of a particular piece of a different coordinate space (the tuple (x, y, z, f)).

People can read multiple copies of a book without interfering with each other, but people can't transmit on the same frequencies without doing so, just as they can't farm the same land without interfering with each other.[2]

> The real free market answer is that electromagnetic radiation is information, and you can generate whatever frequency of it you want, and you assume the markets would naturally orient themselves to not interfere devices.

That's like saying that the real free market answer is to not enforce rights in land, and let the free market work out how to coordinate various uses of land so they don't interference with each other. There is a name for that, it's called the tragedy of the commons.

[1] A "right" deconstructed, just means some legal relationship which the government will enforce on your behalf through violence. Without government, there is no one to enforce rights, and the concept is utterly meaningless. A deer can't invoke its "right to life" when a wolf kills and eats it.

[2] This is an imperfect analogy for various reasons, but more or less true at a very coarse level of granularity.

Re:The Rent Seeking Economy by icebraining on Monday April 15, 2013 @07:55AM (#5550934)
While I do think natural rights are nonsense, I disagree that property rights are necessarily a government construct. There are other institutions regulating property, with enforcement provided by the civil society.