Re:The Rent Seeking Economy
by chii on Sunday April 14, 2013 @11:37PM
(#5549603)
but it is this unhappiness that drives progress - if people are content, there would be no new innovation to try and improve the status quo. If there is no selfishness, there would be no incentive and desire to outdo your neighbour (or competitor).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
So? Why should progress be a goal in and of itself? Shouldn't progress be in the service of something else? If that something else is solving unhappiness, then why do you have a problem if unhappiness is solved through other means and progress becomes obsolete? Perhaps you are just addicted to progress and future-oriented thinking and thus cannot stay happy for long.
so you assume that "solving unhappiness" is the end goal - to which i m arguing that its not. Unhappiness is but a symptom of some problem (currently, its the lack of wealth and material for 90% of the population). If for some reason, everyone managed to get converted into buhdism and not feel any of the unhappiness that they'd otherwise have felt, did the situation really improve? Aren't they just tricking themselves into thinking they are in a state of enlightenment?
There will never be a shortage of malcontents. The rebellion of the 60s sprung from the prosperity of the 50s.
Re:The Rent Seeking Economy
by eli_gottlieb on Monday April 15, 2013 @02:26PM
(#5553212)
Also from the hideously repressive, reactionary and paternalistic social norms of the '50s.
Re:The Rent Seeking Economy
by eli_gottlieb on Monday April 15, 2013 @02:32PM
(#5553247)
This really strongly depends on how you define words like "content" or "unhappiness". If you define them using the lower-brain functions, then your point stands and Total Happiness means everyone has sufficient amounts of beer and television to avoid realizing how empty and stupid their lives are.
If you define them using higher-brain functions, your point falls apart precisely because scientific progress is itself a source of potential contentment.
Re:The Rent Seeking Economy
by OGinparadise on Sunday April 14, 2013 @11:40PM
(#5549614)
On the macro level I totally agree. But on a personal level it may be different, even though we're all benefiting from inventions of those that went nuts and lost many years of sleep