News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Glass was prototyped in one day - with chopsticks by angersock on Sunday April 14, 2013 @06:27PM (#5548641)
Interesting thing here: Google Glass could end up proving to be a really influential product, one that changes a lot of social patterns and app design.

This article seems to suggest that the core UX work could be replicated in a day, just by having normal engineers playing with clay and having a rough idea of what they want.

So, it seems to me, we must ask ourselves: how could you possibly justify patents for such a thing, given how simple it is to come up with?

Re:Google Glass was prototyped in one day - with chopsticks by pbhjpbhj on Sunday April 14, 2013 @07:56PM (#5548947)
>how could you possibly justify patents for such a thing, given how simple it is to come up with //

Patents are awarded on novel inventions. An argument goes that if a particular invention were so simple then why hasn't anyone done it already? Motivation, ability, recompense?

One response is the right-place, right-time, etc.. That's basically the answer that everything would be invented at some point.

However the patent system has an answer to that too - the disclosure of the invention is key to gaining the limited monopoly. Earlier disclosure, as the premise goes, is beneficial to the people of the state granting the monopoly. Thus even if the invention is simple - provided it's not "obvious" [in the domain specific meaning of the term] - then the reward is still being provided for a benefit.

Re:Google Glass was prototyped in one day - with chopsticks by angersock on Sunday April 14, 2013 @08:52PM (#5549128)
But we then look at the fact that, for something that can take a single day to come up with, do we really think a limited monopoly of five or ten years is worth granting?

I think not. In fact, I think that the culture of hacking which has done so much good for this world pretty much demands immediate and unfettered access to the opportunity to play with these ideas.

Re:Google Glass was prototyped in one day - with chopsticks by pbhjpbhj on Monday April 15, 2013 @12:42AM (#5549783)
>unfettered access to the opportunity to play with these ideas. //

Generally patent law allows unfettered access for personal or research purposes, including commercial research, but limits commercial exploitation.

So with [high quality] patents you get access to a vast database of knowledge which would otherwise be locked up in commercial secrets.

Re:Google Glass was prototyped in one day - with chopsticks by vidarh on Monday April 15, 2013 @05:30AM (#5550548)
That's the theory. In reality, how many patents are "high quality"? And how many people actually read them to find ideas, rather than to find ways to work around obstacles?